1. VII. Chosen: The Work of God (8:28-9:24)
    1. D. Salvation By God's Choice Alone (9:14-9:24)

Calvin (12/22/01-12/23/01)

9:14
Flesh always reacts to news of God's predestination by calling Him to accounts, as it were. Thus, Paul always follows teaching on predestination with answers to many of the probable objections. Predestination is indeed a topic that exceeds the mind of man to grasp. However, the Holy Spirit would not teach us of it, were it not to our benefit to know. Thus, the rule must be that what Scripture reveals, we seek to understand, and what Scripture remains silent on, we will not speculate upon. "Monstrous surely is the madness of the human mind ,that it is more disposed to charge God with unrighteousness than to blame itself for blindness." Yet, the flesh is ever inclined to find God unjust when it learns that He has decided for Himself who shall be saved, and who not. Such a thought regarding God ought to be abhorrent to us. The case is explained by presenting two examples, one of election, and one of rejection. In the first, God's mercy is in view, in the second, His justice. That Paul even raises the question of God's possible injustice shows that election is not based on works, for if it were a reaction to our merit, where could we find cause to think God unjust? Note, also, that Paul does not attempt to water down the message because of the troubling thoughts it may excite. He does not attempt to show himself wiser than the Holy Spirit, but declares faithfully what he has heard. So it should always be in our churches. "Let then such magnanimity ever prevail in the Church of God, as that godly teachers may not be ashamed to make an honest confession of the true doctrine, however hated it may be."
9:15
Footnote: By the Hebrew of the quoted passage (Ex 33:19), mercy and compassion would better be rendered as favor and pity. In favoring the elect, God is not unrighteous, but simply favors them with His mercy, yet we will complain unless we can see the reason of His choice. Paul does not soften the blow, he does not seek to declare reasons for God's choosing, but allows the voice of Scripture to answer, considering that sufficient. In this answer which God gave to Moses, we see that His favors are given freely, for no reason other than His own good will. There can be no higher cause for His actions, nor need He defend His choices before any man. Attempts to give bounding causes to God's elections are attempts to bind His freedom. The sole cause of salvation is wrapped up in the favor and pity expressed by God in this passage. Indeed, His mercy is under no restraints, but 'turns wherever it pleases.' Footnote: In thus describing election, the fallen state of man is clear as well, for favor is shown where it is undeserved, and mercy is given to the miserable, not to the innocent. Augustine has said "God makes some vessels of wrath according to their merit; others, vessels of mercy according to His grace."
9:16
"That none of you may think that they who are elected are elected because they are deserving, or because they had in any way procured for themselves the favor of God, or, in short, because they had in them a particle of worthiness by which God might be moved, take simply this view of the matter, that it is neither by our will nor efforts, … that we are counted among the elect, but that it wholly depends on the divine goodness, which of itself chooses those who neither will, nor strive, nor even think of such a thing." Neither willing nor running can accomplish anything on our part. In this, however, we have no excuse for being idle. We are not handed a permit for sloth. Rather, the intent is to remind us "that all we have is from Him, and that we may hence learn to ask all things of Him, hope for all things from Him, and to ascribe all things to Him" as we continue to work out our salvation. Salvation is so completely ascribed to God in this passage, that nothing remains for man to contribute to the cause. Footnote: The running and the willing point back to the tail of Esau. Isaac willed to bless him. Esau ran to obtain the blessing. Isaac, in so willing, acted as though unaware of God's declaration at Esau's birth. Rebecca, in working to block Isaac's intended blessing of Esau, was no less sinful, for by her actions she showed that she thought God unable to fulfill His own word. "It was the trial of faith, and the faith of both halted exceedingly; yet the purpose of God was still fulfilled." Others have attempted to explain away this passage by applying it only to the ungodly. All these arguments are the results of minds that remain stubborn. Rather than try to smooth the roughness of God's word, they should bend their own stubbornness to become obedient to the Holy Spirit.
9:17
Exodus 9:16 is taken as the example of God's work with the unredeemed. Here, it is shown that as much as Pharaoh sought to resist God, God was shown invincible. First, we may consider that Pharaoh was predestined to ruin before ever this resistance was shown. Secondly we may dwell on God's purpose in this, which He declares was to make His name known. If the hardening came in such a way as to glorify God, how impious it is to claim Him unrighteous because of it. In the Hebrew, 'raised up' is more properly 'appointed.' God appointed Pharaoh to the task of resisting His efforts to deliver Israel. God not only knew ahead of time that Pharaoh would react in this fashion, He ordained that it would be so, so that He might give glorious evidence of His own power. Footnote: raised up, or appointed? The word in the Hebrew of the quoted passage certainly speaks more of appointing, establishing, or otherwise setting in place. It is from the Septuagint that the idea of preservation comes, which Paul has modified somewhat, using a term that indicates raising up, a term he only uses on one other place, where he is speaking of the resurrection. All of these varied meanings seem to apply to the case of Pharaoh. God appointed him for this purpose. He preserved him through the plagues that had already come against him, hardening him to continue on his course. He had raised Pharaoh up from the 'jaws of death' in so preserving him. To maintain the idea of preservation in this passage is unfitting. It is the beginnings of Pharaoh's activities that are in view, and these are laid firmly at the feet of God. He had ordained that it be so. Even the reprobate, then, proceeds from the 'hidden fountain of His providence.'
9:18
In conclusion, Paul reminds us to look no further than God's will in seeking reason for election or rejection. To whom He wills, He wills. "Beyond this He allows us not to proceed." Hardening is more than permission, it is the active operation of God's wrath. In this sense, Satan remains a minister of God, for he acts only as he is commanded. Footnote: When hardening is an action of God, it cannot in itself be sinful. It is a displaying of His wrath that He provides opportunities for the rebellious to rebel the more, and so increase their own sinfulness. In doing so, He chooses for His own reasons, known only to Himself, to display His glory in one fashion rather than another. What Paul declares here, God teaches; that the destruction of the wicked is not simply foreknown by God, but that they are created for that very purpose. To this, Solomon's words also testify. (Pr 16:4 - GOD has made everything for its own purpose, even the wicked for the day of evil.) Footnote: Even if this be objected to as an inappropriate proof text for God's role in reprobation, yet the doctrine stands clearly declared in this chapter of Romans, and in the history of God's providence.
9:19
It is ever the nature of fallen man to blame God rather than themselves. To find that He has declared the reprobate's condemnation from the beginning gives rise to the thought in them that God is unrighteous in so choosing their end before the beginning. In their minds, there is a new issue that arises when they ascribe to God the authority that is His. Now they see Him as a tyrant, forcing men to act as they do, and so they find cause to question His justice when men follow His irresistible will for them.
9:20
Before arguing God's righteousness, Paul shows man his true position. "Who disputes with God?" he asks. That God's will is indeed the sole determinant in man's salvation or condemnation is confirmed by Paul's not declaring their argument invalid. It is indeed only by God's will that men are saved or condemned. In this much they are correct. Paul does not lack an answer to defend God's justice. He does, however, recognize that such as are offering this sort of argument must be brought gradually to the answer, else they'll never understand it. Thus, he only presents a partial answer, though one sufficient to show God's justice, when it's considered with humility. Neither does God refrain from answering the charge for lack of answer. No, He knows the limits of our minds, and so, He keeps the answer wrapped in mystery. Again, what God chooses not to reveal, we ought not to chase answers for, but ought, as He does, regard our own weakness, and know our limits. Paul reminds us that God's counsels must be known just by us, even if we may not understand them. Though it makes us uncomfortable to know ourselves formed for His purpose solely because He so willed it, yet we must recognize that His choices are just, whether we understand or not. Some think Paul alludes to Jer 18:6 - (Can't I deal with Israel as the potter deals with his clay? Indeed, Israel is just like that clay in My hands.) However, that passage deals only with God's ability to break Israel should He so choose. A better choice is Isa 45:9 - (Woe to him who would quarrel with his Maker, to him who is just one earthen vessel amongst many. Will he indeed require of his Maker, 'what are You doing?' Will the thing made claim that its maker has no hands?) No great effort needs to be expended over this passage, as Paul is simply calling on the testimony of the prophet to reinforce his own argument. Footnote: An even closer parallel is found to Isa 29:16 - (Shall the potter be thought equal to the clay? Will the pot say to its maker, 'He didn't make me?' Will the thing formed claim that its former has no understanding?)
9:21
Our right of contention is removed by the simple fact that the potter is well within his rights to form whatever he will from his clay. It is not arbitrary power that God displays, but His just rights in forming His creations as He will. Bear in mind also that the potter takes away nothing from his clay, no matter how he may form it. So it is with God and man. He takes nothing away from us, even if we are formed for destruction. However, to deny Him His rights over His creation, would be to take away from Him an honor that is properly His. Footnote: The conclusion drawn by Calvin here does not fit the context, for the next verse makes clear that Paul is looking at the whole of fallen man, in the allusion to the clay. It is in this context that that same metaphor is used in the prophets, and it is this understanding that is consistent with Paul's own teaching. (Eph 2:3 - We, too, used to live in the lusts of our flesh, indulging them. We were by nature children of wrath, just as they are. Isa 64:8 - LORD, You are our Father. We are clay, and You our potter. We are all works of Your hand. Isa 64:6a - For all of us are unclean, and our most righteous deeds are but filthy rags.) From this, it becomes clear that when God declares that He will have mercy on whom He will, He is looking upon the whole of fallen man, none of whom could be considered as deserving such mercy.)
9:22
While unwilling to pursue answers as to the reason for God's choice (for such are beyond comprehension), he yet offers examples by which it becomes clear that God's justice is no less gloriously displayed in punishment than in forgiveness. However His predestination may show itself in a life, it remains perfectly just. There is an implied understanding that we cannot charge Him with injustice for being patient in enduring the presence of such fallen creatures as ourselves. If God chooses to bear with these vessels of wrath for a time, rather than destroy them immediately, what cause for reproach is that? If, in so doing, His mercy toward the elect is made the more evident, there is still no cause to question His justice. No reason for His choosing is offered, because He does not reveal His counsels to man. Yet, we ought to revere His justice, rather than question it. Vessels are instruments used for a purpose. Those who are vessels of wrath are used for the purpose of making God's judgments visible. Those who are vessels of mercy are used for the purpose of displaying His mercy before man.
9:23
In the destruction of the reprobate, God's mercy toward the elect is shown all the greater, for nothing can be found in the elect that is different from those destroyed, except that God delivers them. When we consider those who will not escape His wrath, we have all the more cause to praise Him for His mercy toward us. Glory is the effect caused by His display of mercy. (Eph 1:13-14 - After you heard the message of truth, the gospel of your salvation, and believed in Him, you were sealed with the Holy Spirit of promise, given you as a pledge of your inheritance, the redemption of God's own possession to the praise of His glory.) So, through saving these vessels of mercy, God glorifies Himself. Whether for wrath or mercy, the preparations are connected with the secret counsels of God.
9:24
From all that he has reasoned, it becomes clear first, that salvation cannot be restricted to the Jews, and secondly, that it cannot be insisted that salvation apply to all Jews. If election is solely by God's will, then it exists wherever His will may turn. Now that election is established, Paul can turn to the issues of Gentile inclusion and Jewish rejection. He wisely begins with the less offensive issue of inclusion. We are vessels of His glory, taken both from the Gentiles and the Jews, for nations are no impediment to God's purpose.
 
 
 

Matthew Henry (12/24/01)

9:14
Paul seeks to prove God's sovereignty in dealing with mankind. If God's choosing of some and not others is as arbitrary as it appears, could it not be supposed that He is unrighteous in some of His choices? Paul rejects that thought vehemently. (Ge 18:25 - Far be it from God to slay the righteous with the wicked. The Judge of the whole earth will surely deal justly! Ro 3:5-6 - If our unrighteousness shows how righteous God is, can we claim Him unrighteous when He is wrathful? No way! How else could He judge the world, except He be a righteous Judge?) Now, he moves on prove the truth of what he has denied as possible.
9:15
Paul gives us God's own testimony to show that 'all God's reasons of mercy are taken from within Himself.' "He will do what He will, and giveth not account of any of His matters, nor is it fit He should." (Ex 3:14 - I AM WHO I AM. Tell them that I AM has sent you.) This declaration shows God's absolute independence. The current passage shows that His will is equally absolute. He is righteous because He is competent to judge all things, even Himself. What He begins, He completes. "Therefore God's mercy endures forever, because the reason of it is fetched from within Himself."
9:16
Whatever good man may have of God, it is due solely to His free grace and mercy. That Rebecca desired for Jacob to have the blessing did not cause the blessing to come. That Jacob was quick to run and obtain that blessing did not cause the blessing to come. Only the mercy and grace of God brought that blessing upon Jacob. It is that same grace of God that causes His people to be different; holy and happy. In the present case, the Gentiles were brought and the Jews rejected by and large, not because the Gentiles had shown themselves somehow more deserving, but simply because God disposed Himself to be gracious to them. (Mt 4:16 - The people sitting in darkness saw a great light. Upon those who dwell in the land and shadow of death, a light has dawned.) They were content in that darkness, and neither desired nor sought the light that came. (Isa 65:1 - I allowed Myself to be sought by those who did not ask for Me, to be found by those who did not seek Me.) Thus, God ever causes His grace to be known. Thus, if any have any good of God, it is not cause for us to speak evil of Him, but to give Him glory. (Ps 115:1 - Not to us, but to Your name give glory because of Your lovingkindness and truth.)
9:17
In the case of Pharaoh, it was God who created him, made him famous, and gave him his kingdom and power. He was set in high places, so as to be a beacon as the plagues came against his hardened heart. (Ex 4:21 - Return to Egypt, and be certain to perform all the wonders I have put in your power before Pharaoh's eyes. However, I will harden his heart, and he will not allow the people to leave.) This hardening was nothing but the removal of grace, and allowing him to follow his own inclinations. (Pr 16:4 - The LORD has made everything for its own purpose, even the wicked for the day of evil. Mt 11:23 - Capernaum will not be exalted, but will descend to Hades; for it has seen so many miracles. Had Sodom seen such miracles, it would remain, but Capernaum was unaffected by it all.) All was done to give honor to God's name. If Pharaoh had not been so mighty, God's power in ruining him would have been less glorious. But the defeat of such a tyrant, of one who trampled on justice, proclaimed God glorious in His holiness. (Ex 15:11 - Who is like Thee, oh LORD? Who else is so majestic in holiness, awesome in praises? Who else works such wonders?)
9:18
God is indebted to none, but can dispense His grace as He pleases. "Those who are saved must thank God only, and those who perish must thank themselves only." (Hos 13:9 - Your destruction comes, oh Israel, in being against Me, against your help.) We are bound by God to do all we can to bring men to salvation, but God is bound only by such covenants as He has made in accord with His own good pleasure. He has promised to receive all that come to Christ, but the drawing of souls to come to Christ is a matter of His favors, which He will give to whom He will. (Lk 10:21 - I praise Thee, O Father, Lord of heaven and earth, that You hid these things from the wise, and yet revealed them to babes. For thus it was well-pleasing in Your sight.)
9:19
If indeed God gives effectual grace to some, and denies it to others, how can He fault those others for their blindness? If their reprobate actions are in accord with His will, how is it to be counted against them?
9:20
It is not fitting that the creature should offer such objections to his Creator. "It becomes us to submit to Him, not to reply against Him." We are His servants, and ought not to argue with our Master. (Tit 2:9 - Slaves, be subject to your own masters in everything, well-pleasing and not argumentative.) It is unbecoming of us to complain of the form given us by our Maker. His sovereignty over us is no different than that of the potter over his clay. (Jer 18:6 - Can I not deal with Israel as a potter does his clay? Indeed, you are like clay in the potter's hands to Me, oh Israel.)
9:21
Out of the same clay, the potter may make one vessel for honorable use, and another for contemptible use. He could as well have chosen to leave the clay in the ground, completely unused.
9:22
So, God makes two types of vessels from fallen mankind; vessels of wrath and vessels of mercy. Vessels of wrath are filled with His wrath, as a wine bottle is filled with wine. (Isa 51:20 - Your sons have fainted, and lie helpless in every street, like antelopes in a net. They are full of the wrath of the LORD, of God's rebuke.) God will have it known in the world that He hates sin, and it is to make this known that He punishes by His wrath. In showing Himself powerful against sin, He shows His glory. (2Th 1:9 - They pay the penalty of eternal destruction, forever separated from the presence of the Lord, and the glory of His power.) God's patience in delaying has been great. He has left sinners alone, to complete their sins, to make themselves fit for destruction. (Mt 23:32 - Fill up the measure of your fathers' guilt, Mt 23:35 - that the guilt of all the righteous blood ever shed on the earth might fall upon you; from Abel right on through Zechariah, whom you slew even on the Temple grounds.) By their own obstinacy, they made themselves fit for destruction.
9:23
The happiness of the saved comes not from their merit, but from God's mercy, which endures forever. In displaying His goodness in us, He makes His glory known. "God's goodness is His greatest glory." (Ex 33:18-19 - Moses: "I pray that You would show me Your glory!" God: "I will make all My goodness pass before you, and will proclaim the name of the LORD before you. I will be gracious to whom I will, and compassionate towards whom I will.") God makes His goodness known in providing for every creature. But when He wishes to display the riches of that goodness, He shows it in the salvation of the saints, an eternal monument to His grace. "Sanctification is the preparation of the soul for glory." "We can destroy ourselves fast enough, but we cannot save ourselves. Sinners fit themselves for hell, but it is God that prepares saints for heaven." (2Co 5:5 - He who prepared us for this purpose is God, who gave us the Spirit as a pledge.)
9:24
Whom He predestinated, He effectually called, from amongst both Jews and Gentiles. The dividing wall has been removed, the playing field leveled, and now the whole world stands before God with equal possibility of salvation, whether of Abraham's seed or not. It is now solely a matter of His call, which is according to His purpose.
 
 

Adam Clarke (12/25/01)

9:14
"Whatever God does is right." There is no injustice to be found in His choosing to give special privileges to some and not to others.
9:15
In His promise to Moses, God declared that He would so display Himself as to convince Moses completely of His kindness. Yet, He would remain indebted to none, as to how He dispenses His mercies. He spared the Jews on that occasion not because of Moses' intercession, but because of His own sovereign choice. It is for Him to choose how and if salvation will be granted, and He has chosen Jesus Christ, His Son, as the how. "He will never change His purpose."
9:16
Neither the will of Abraham and Isaac, nor the running of Esau were of any effect in changing the course of God's will. When the chosen forfeited their privileges by their apostasy, it was not Moses' will that held them, nor was God encumbered by prior obligations. It was His own sovereign mercy that kept them.
9:17
God would have been equally just to allow the Jews to continue in their sins until He determined in His wisdom to destroy them. Thus it was with Pharaoh, whom He restored after each of the several plagues, so that his final destruction should be the more noteworthy. It was for this purpose that Pharaoh was preserved: to more fully demonstrate God's power.
9:18
Whether it be the mercy of salvation, or the forbearance of sins leading to destruction, God works according to His own will, in His perfect wisdom and righteousness. Those being hardened in sin can yet prevent their destruction if they will but turn to Jesus, the real Messiah.
9:19
Here are echoes of Romans 3:7 (If my lie shows God's truth to be all the more glorious, why am I considered a sinner?) If God's glory is promoted by my rebellious nature, and He permits me to follow that path, what reason is there to punish me for doing that which accords with His good pleasure?
9:20
As one who has consistently abused God's grace, and rebelled against His rule, how dare you to complain of His dispensation concerning you? You, who have so corrupted yourself, will you attempt to correct the all-wise God of grace, and complain that He has wronged you? This passage gets heavily abused by those that wish to claim for themselves that infallible leading by which Paul wrote. Pulling this verse in the course of theological debate is more diabolical than it is godly.
9:21
(Jer 18:1-10 - The LORD told me to go and observe the potter, which doing, I saw him making something on his wheel. However, that which he was making was spoiled in his hands, so he reshaped it into another vessel, making it as he pleased. At that, the LORD asked, "Can I not deal with Israel as this potter does his clay? Truly, you are like that clay in My hands, Israel. If I have determined to destroy a nation, but that nation repents of its evils, I will not bring that calamity upon them as I had planned. By the same token, if I have determined to bless a nation, but that nation does evil in my sight, and disobeys me, I will think better of my plans to bless them.") God is perfectly within His rights to form each of us as He sees fit, for whatever purpose He may have in mind. The reference Paul makes to this passage in Jeremiah shows that he is considering nations and not individuals.
9:22
The example of Egypt, represented by Pharaoh, shows God's patience in the face of their obstinate rebellion. Clearly, the hardening of their hearts was due to their own refusal of God's grace, their abuse of His goodness. Eventually, this hardening positioned them for the time of destruction. As it had been for them, so now, the Jews were bringing the same fate upon themselves. "They were ripe for punishment; and that power which God was making known for their salvation, having been so long and so much abused and provoked, was now about to show itself in their destruction as a nation." Yet, this is not a final and irrevocable word against them. Such an eternal decree as predestination to damnation could never come from God, and cannot be supported by Paul's words.
9:23
God's patience with them was so as to show His power in venting His wrath against them, as well as in displaying the magnificence of His glory in the mercy shown to those He has saved. Although they had long since deserved destruction, God waited for the proper time. (Ps 110:2 - The LORD will send forth His scepter from Zion to rule in the midst of His enemies.) He had determined that the first preachers of His Gospel would come from Jerusalem. For this, He waited, waiting longer, to make certain that the seed of that message had taken root in the Gentile nations. He had allowed the Jews to fight against His grace, rejecting those the Lord had accepted. (Ro 9:33 - I lay in Zion a rock of offense, and them who believe in Him will not be disappointed. Ro 10:3 - Not knowing God's righteousness, they sought to establish their own, refusing to subject themselves to the righteousness of God. Ro 11:11-12 - Yet, their stumbling was not so as to fall completely. By their rebellions, the Gentiles have been saved, so as to make them jealous. If their transgressions are such a blessing for the world, if their failures have so blessed the Gentiles, imagine what will come of their fulfillment! Ro 11:15 - If their rejection reconciled the world to God, what will their acceptance bring, but life from the dead! Ro 11:28 - They are as enemies of the Gospel from your viewpoint, yet they remain God's beloved, because of the fathers. Ro 11:30-31 - Even as you used to disobey, but have been shown mercy because of their disobedience, so they, too, who are now disobeying, may be shown mercy.)
9:24
He has displayed His great mercy on all those, Jews and Gentiles alike, who have "been invited by the preaching of the Gospel to receive justification by faith in our Lord Jesus Christ, and have come to the Gospel feast on this invitation."
 
 
 

Barnes' Notes (12/25/01-12/27/01)

9:14
People are forever charging God with injustice, when they come up against this doctrine, but He never does wrong. Paul shows that this doctrine is nothing new, but is the same as was taught most explicitly in the Old Testament, as founded on principles of equity and justice.
9:15
The full passage from which this quote is taken shows God displaying His mercy, and His choosing of whom He would apply that mercy to, were the best proof of His benevolence. There was not one among all the human race that deserved that mercy. Those to whom He was merciful, He chose according to His own will, for no other consideration. How it is He will have mercy on His chosen objects is not declared. However, it is made clear that it is His sovereign choice, for which He is not obliged to give account to any man. His choice is made without concern for any claim of merit that man might bring, for man is wholly devoid of merit in His sight. The extent, time, and manner of His mercy being shown are matters of His good pleasure, and nothing else. He has in mind a definite number upon which He intends to display His mercies, to whom He intends to provide eternal life. In sight of all this, none has a right to complain. That any are saved at all is sufficient proof of His benevolence, and considering that we are all justly condemned, He is perfectly within His rights to pardon whomsoever He pleases, just as any national executive may pardon whom he will. "It should be a matter of joy that any can be pardoned and saved, and not a subject of murmuring and complaint."
9:16
Upon this statement of God to Moses, we found the following doctrine: Eternal life is granted not because of any disposition on man's part to be saved, nor because of any great effort on his part. In this, man is not stripped of his choosing, nor is God found to force men into heaven against their will. No, but the influence of the Holy Spirit is such as to make them willing. (Ps 110:3a - The people will volunteer freely in the day of Thy power.) Neither is the point of this passage that Christians make no effort. Indeed, Scripture teaches that all who are saved do indeed strive to enter the kingdom. (Lk 16:16 - Since John has come, the gospel of God's kingdom is preached, and people are forcing their way into it. Lk 13:24 - Strive to enter by the narrow gate, for may will seek it and yet be unable to enter.) "There is no effort more intense and persevering, no struggle more arduous or agonizing, than when a sinner seeks eternal life." (Mt 7:7-8 - Ask, and it shall be given; seek, and you will find; knock, and it shall be opened to you. Every one that asks, receives; he who seeks, finds; and to him who knocks, it shall be opened.) However, a sinner will not put forth any effort to save himself. His pardon, then, comes not because he has made any effort, but because God chooses to pardon him. No amount of prayer, no depth of anxiety over our condition, no amount of effort on our part to change can put God under obligation to us. Indeed, the sinner ought to be anxious as to his fate, and ought to pray his heart out, yet there is no merit in that. When all is said and done, yet it remains a matter of God's sovereign mercy, as to whether he will be saved or lost. "Salvation in its beginning, its progress, and its close, is of Him."
9:17
(Ex 9:16 - For this purpose, I have allowed you to remain, so as to show you My power, and to so proclaim My name through all the earth. Gal 3:8 - Scripture, knowing God would justify the Gentiles by faith, preached the Gospel to Abraham beforehand, in declaring that all nations would be blessed in him. Gal 3:22 - Scripture shut all up under sin, so that the promise in Jesus Christ by faith might be given to them that believe.) God has a right to pass by whom He will, and to so order their circumstances that their true character is developed. Even the mightiest of nations are yet under His control. (Isa 10:5-7 - Assyria, the rod and staff of My anger, My indignation, I send against godless nations, commissioning it against the people I am furious with. There, they capture and plunder, trampling the people as mud in the street. Yet, this is not their intent, nor the plan they have in mind. Rather, they plan to destroy utterly, to cut off nations.) Pharaoh was sustained by God, preserved from ruin, and strengthened, for one purpose. This is not to say that God worked any positive evil upon Pharaoh's mind, nor that He directly influenced and excited Pharaoh to evil, only that He kept Pharaoh in such circumstances as would serve to develop his true character to the fullest. God had a great purpose in Pharaoh's existence, and in his conduct. It was because of this purpose that He preserved him. It was well within His control to take the monarch's life, or not. In that He controlled all those things that could influence Pharaoh's feelings one way or the other, He controlled Pharaoh himself. His choice was to keep him in such circumstances as would develop his true character, yet in all these circumstances, Pharaoh acted freely, pursuing his own course. His opposition to God was voluntary. (Ex 8:15 - When he saw that there was relief from the plague, he hardened his own heart, and would not listen, even as the LORD had said.) None can blame God for placing them in such situations as show their true character. None are compelled to sin, nor is God obliged to save them that have no desire to be saved. God's greatest acts of power were shown in delivering His people from such a tyrant, and His name, the name of the only true God, was made known by His actions on Israel's behalf. God's primary design in governing the world is to make His name, His power, and His character known. This is often accomplished by the destruction of the wicked. Thus, the wicked ought to be alarmed, for they cannot in any way contend with God. His enemies shall be destroyed. It is right and just that the wicked should thus be cut off. The trial has been fair. In all circumstances, he has shown himself unwilling to obey God, and nothing in justice or mercy hinders God from consigning such a one to death.
9:18
Again, hardening is no positive influence exerted by God, but rather a leaving of the sinner to his own course. (Jn 12:40 - He has blinded them, and hardened their hearts, lest they see and perceive with the heart, and so be converted, such that I might heal them.) It is God's sovereign choice that determines Him to leave the sinner to his choices, and not influence him toward salvation. No reason is offered for the choice, yet it should be clear that His reasons are wrapped up in His infinite wisdom and integrity.
9:19
If all man's rebellion against God are truly in accord with His own decree, doing nothing to frustrate His plans, how is it that He can blame people? So the complaint has gone throughout the ages, as sinners object to the doctrines of grace. It comes as a reaction to the problem of reconciling God's purposes and man's free will. It assumes, with no evidence, that God's plans must destroy man's freedom. Seeing God's plans accomplished, this complaint assumes that what has been done must be for the best, and so man cannot be blamed for his part in it. What is said here is not that none have tried to resist God, but that none have succeeded in doing so. (Eph 6:13 - Take up the whole armor of God, so as to resist in the evil day. Lk 21:15 - I will give you wise words which no opponent will be able to resist or refute. Ac 13:8 - Elymas the magician was opposing them, trying to keep the proconsul from faith. Ro 13:2 - He who resists authority opposes God's Law. They who have opposed will receive condemnation. Gal 2:11 - When Cephas came to Antioch, I opposed him to his face.) It was long established fact that God is irresistible. (2Ch 20:6 - LORD, are you not God in the heavens? Do you not rule over all kingdoms and nations? Power and might are in Your hand, and none can stand against You. Da 4:35 - All who dwell on earth are together counted as nothing, for He does according to His will in heaven and on earth, and none can stop His hand, or require an account of Him for what He has done. Ge 50:20 - You meant to do me evil, but God meant it for good, to bring this result, and preserve many alive.)
9:20
Paul first shows that God is sovereign, having the right to do His will, then moves to show that in doing so, justice and mercy are upheld. To arraign God as a wrongdoer is most impious. It is improper that the creature should so accost his Maker. He is unqualified in the finitude of his mind to pass judgment on the Infinite Mind, having not the faculties to assess, nor the authority to offer his decision. Even if he were qualified, there would yet be no right. "There has been no point in the Christian theology to which the human heart has been so ready to make objections as to the doctrine of the sovereignty of God." "When God declares His will, man should be still." We cannot argue His injustice, because we cannot understand His reasons for acting. Given that Paul's argument is made against a supposed Jewish objection, it is fitting that he turn to Scripture to answer them. Here, he turns to Isaiah. (Isa 29:16 - Shall the potter be thought equal with the clay? Will what is made claim its maker did not make it, or will it claim that its maker has no understanding? Isa 45:9 - Woe to him who quarrels with his Maker. He is but one earthenware vessel among many. Will that clay ask the potter what he is doing? Will the thing claim its maker has no hands?) Every being is within its rights to fashion his work as he sees best. What is not denied to man ought not to be denied to God, nor ought we fault Him for acting in such ways. "They who have received every blessing they enjoy from Him, ought not to blame Him for not making them different."
9:21
Another reference is made to Isaiah. (Isa 64:6-8 - We are all unclean, our best deeds no more than filthy garments. We wither like a leaf, as our sins take us away like a wind. None can be found who calls on Your name, who exerts himself to hold on to You, for You have hidden Your face from us and delivered us into the power of our own sins. O LORD, You are our Father. We are clay, and You our potter. Every one of us are the work of Your hands.) By our actions, none can claim to deserve God's mercy. Since none merit it, He is free to give it to whom He will, just as the potter is free to form what he will of his clay. So it continues today. Yet, no injustice is done to a man, when he is left to his own course, and that course leads to ruin. No man's rights have been violated when not all have the brilliant mind of a Newton, nor the blessed circumstances of a Peter or a Paul. None suffer more than they deserve, nor will any arrive in hell thinking they have a claim to be treated better. Here, there are echoes of Jeremiah. (Jer 18:6 - Can I not deal with you as the potter does? You are like clay in My hand, Israel.) Isaiah shows God sovereign over individuals, Jeremiah shows Him equally sovereign over nations. However, in the example of the potter, we are to see only God's right in acting, not the mode in which He acts, for holiness is not formed in a man by simple act of power, but by an inclining of their will to receive God's favors. (Ps 110:3 - Your people will volunteer freely in the day of Your power.) The view here is not to original creation, but to current condition. All of mankind is in ruins, fallen from grace and without claim on God. All deserve death, so He may give life to whom He pleases without trampling the rights of those who remain. The power of the potter is not physical ability, but authority. (Mt 7:29 - He was teaching them as one having authority, not like their scribes. 2Th 3:9 - It is not that we have no right to your support, but we prefer to be a model to you, that you might follow our example, and support yourselves. Mk 2:10, Lk 5:24 - The Son of Man has authority on earth to forgive sins.) The lump is anything that is reduced to fine powder and mixed with water to make it soft. It could be clay or dough. (Ro 11:16 - If the first piece is holy, the lump is also. 1Co 5:6 - A little leaven leavens the whole lump.) Here, the lump represents the mass of sinners, with no claim on God. The potter shows God's right to use that mass as seems good to Him. We are left with no reason or right to complain if God blesses whom He will.
9:22
Is not God right, then, in what He does both to the sinner and the saint? If He is right in both cases, then He is right in all cases, for all of mankind falls into one or the other of these categories. "If it is right to do a thing, it is right to purpose or intend to do it." Wrath most properly means a vehement desire to attain something. Generally, it has reflected an earnest desire for revenge. (Eph 4:31 - Let all bitterness, wrath, anger, and slander be put away from you, along with any malice. Col 3:8 - Put them all aside: anger, wrath, malice, slander, and abusive speech. 1Ti 2:8 - I want every man to pray, lifting holy hands without wrath and dissension. Mk 3:5 - He looked at them with anger, grieved at the hardness of their heart. Then he restored the man's hand. Ro 1:18 - The wrath of God is revealed against all ungodliness and unrighteousness, for men suppress the truth in unrighteousness. Lk 3:7 - You vipers, who warned you to flee from the wrath to come? Lk 21:23 - Woe to those with child in those days, for there will be great distress on the land, and wrath to this people.) It is surely right for God to show His wrath against sin. It would be improper for Him not to so; to approve of it, or be indifferent to it. However, God takes no pleasure either in sin, or its punishment. By no act has He compelled man to sin. The case of Pharaoh was but one example of the general principle. So God would deal with sinful man, for His government of mankind follows 'great and uniform principles.' Yet, He has been patient. (Rev 2:3 - You have perseverance and have endured for My sake. You have not grown weary. 1Co 13:7 - Love bears, believes, hopes, and endures all things. Lk 18:7 - God will bring justice for His elect. They cry out to Him constantly; will He then delay long in answering them?) He has borne with us, allowing us to live when we deserved to die. He has offered us pardon, and blessed us greatly. What right, then, for us to complain of His government? Like a clay cup, our bodies are easily broken, so vessel comes to symbolize the body. (2Co 4:7 - We have this treasure in earthen vessels, so that the greatness of God's power is evident, and not any power of our own. 1Th 4:4 - Each of you knows how to keep your vessel sanctified and honorable. Ac 9:15 - The Lord said, "Go, for he is a chosen instrument of Mine, to bear My name before Gentiles and kings and the sons of Israel. Isa 13:5 - They come from a far country, the LORD and His instruments of indignation, to destroy the land. Jn 17:12 - While I was with them, I kept them in Your name which You have given Me. I guarded them, and not one perished but the son of perdition.) God's punishment is carried out against those that properly deserve it. It is not some matter of our physical nature, it is a matter of 'long continuance in iniquity.' It is not arbitrary appointment, but consequence of actions taken. To be prepared, or fitted, is to be made complete, restored, adapted to, or prepared for a purpose. (Mt 4:21 - He saw James and John in a boat with their father, mending their nets. Gal 6:1 - If a man is caught in any sin, you who are spiritual should restore him in a spirit of gentleness; considering your own situation, lest you also be tempted. Heb 11:3 - By faith we understand that the worlds were prepared by the word of God, that which is seen not being made from anything visible. Heb 10:5 - He comes into the world saying, "You have not desired a sacrifice or an offering, but You have prepared a body for Me." Ps 68:10b - You provided Your goodness for the poor, O God. Ps 74:16 - Day and night are Yours. You have prepared the light and the sun.) Nothing is said as to how they became properly suited for destruction, only that they did become so. It must be carefully noted that the passage we are looking at does not say that God prepared them for destruction, whereas it does say He prepares vessels of mercy. (Mt 25:34 - The King will say to the right hand, "Come, you who are blessed of My Father, and inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the beginning." Mt 25:41 - To the left hand, He will say, "Depart from Me, accursed ones, into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels.") Thus, God keeps in view the truth that He exerts His direct agency in preparing the elect for heaven, but does not exert His direct agency in preparing the wicked for destruction. "Destruction" occurs 20 times in the New Testament. (Mt 7:13 - The gate is wide and broad that leads to destruction, and many enter by it. Jn 17:12 - None perished but the son of perdition, that Scripture might be fulfilled. Ac 8:20 - May your silver perish with you, who thought to buy God's gifts! Php 1:28 - Don't be alarmed by your opponents. This is a sign of destruction for them, but of salvation for you, and that, from God. Php 3:19 - Their end is destruction, and their god is their own appetite. They glory in their shame, setting their minds on earthly things. 2Th 2:3-4 - Don't be deceived. The completion will not come unless the apostasy comes first, and the man of lawlessness is revealed, the son of destruction who opposes and exalts himself above every object of worship, seeking to show himself God. Heb 10:39 - We are not those who retreat to destruction, but those who have faith that preserves the soul. 2Pe 2:1 - False prophets arose among the people, just as false teachers will come among you, introducing destructive heresies, and denying the Master who bought them. They bring swift destruction upon themselves. 2Pe 2:3 - They will exploit you with false words. Their judgment is long established, and is not idle. Their destruction is not sleeping. 2Pe 3:7 - This present heaven and earth are reserved for fire, kept for judgment day, the day of destruction of ungodly men. 2Pe 3:16 - Some of what Paul teaches is very hard to understand. Unstable men distort his writings just as they distort the rest of Scripture, to their own destruction.) In all these, the view is to a future punishment, not to some national calamity. If, then, people are suited to destruction, it is fit that they should be subjected to the torments they have suited themselves to. God will surely do what is fit and right, and if they will not repent, they must perish. It would not be right for God to take them to heaven as they are, for they are not suited to that place.
9:23
The treatment of the sinner has been shown just. Now, we look at the treatment of the redeemed. If this, also, is shown just, then the totality of God's government is shown righteous. (Eph 1:18 - I pray that your heart be enlightened, so as to know the hope of His calling, and what are the riches of the glory of His inheritance in the saints.) It is His abundant glory, which He has displayed in His mercy toward those He has chosen to be merciful to. Whereas grace is a gift to one undeserving, mercy is a gift to one in distress. Whereas the means by which the wicked are fit for destruction is not noted, the means by which the redeemed are prepared for glory is directly attributed to God. (1Th 5:9 - God has not destined us to wrath, but to salvation through our Lord Jesus Christ. 2Ti 1:9 - He has saved us, calling us with a holy calling, not because our works have deserved it, but for His own purpose and grace, granted to us in Christ Jesus from the beginning of time. Eph 1:4-5 - He chose us before the world began, to be holy and blameless before Him. In His love, He predestined us to adoption as sons through Jesus Christ, according to His kind will. Ro 8:28-30 - We know God orders events such that they work for our good, as we love God, and are called according to His purpose. Those He foreknew, He predestined to be conformed to His Son's image, making Him first-born of many brethren. And those He predestined, He also called; and calling, justified; and justifying, also glorified. Ac 13:48 - When the Gentiles heard this, they rejoiced and glorified God's word. All whom God had appointed to eternal life believed. Jn 1:13 - Such were born not of blood, nor of their own or any other man's will, but of God.) None could possibly complain because God has done good, which He has certainly done in improving man by renewal and sanctification. All has been done to prepare these elect individuals for heaven. (Heb 2:10 - It was fitting for Him, Who is the source and purpose of all things, to perfect the author of Salvation through sufferings, such that He brought many sons to glory. Ro 5:2 - Through Jesus Christ, our Lord, we are introduced by faith into the grace in which we now stand, and we exalt in hope of the glory of God. 2Co 4:17 - These passing and light afflictions are producing a weighty eternal glory which is far beyond comparison. 2Th 2:14 - It was for this that He called you, that you may gain the glory of our Lord Jesus Christ. 2Ti 2:10 - For this, I endure all things for the sake of the chosen, that they, too, may obtain the salvation which is in Christ Jesus, and with it eternal glory. 1Pe 5:4 - When the Chief Shepherd appears, you will receive a crown of glory that will never fade.) That glory combines all that is honorable, dignified, pure, and loving; all that is fit to produce happiness. Scripture never applies this glory to some national privilege, or calling. No nation has ever been declared as 'prepared unto glory.' As this glory is a future issue, it shows that the destruction it is contrasted to is also a future issue. All people will be dealt with according to their character in the end. If all injustice is absent, then all must be dealt with justly. The just result of wickedness is eternal punishment. Where all are undeserving, God may bless whom He pleases in all righteousness. Paul certainly believes this is how God deals with man, else he would not work so hard to defend the idea.
9:24
Now, he returns to a primary point of this letter: that the Gentiles were as likely to be called of God as the Jews. (Ro 1:16 - The gospel is the power of God to all who believe, the Jew and also the Greek. Ro 2:10 - Glory and honor and peace come to every man who does good, both Jew and Greek. Ro 3:29-30 - Is God only God of the Jews? No. He is also God of the Gentiles, since He who will justify the circumcised by faith, and the uncircumcised through faith is One.) Clearly, 'us' refers to Christians, and not to some nation or other. The doctrine stated is a matter for individuals. God's grace is shown not to be restricted to the Jews alone, nor is God required to be gracious to all of Abraham's descendants.
 
 
 

Wycliffe (12/27/01)

9:14
That God's choices are not based on our works does not make Him unrighteous. He is sovereign.
9:15
God's declaration to Moses, quoted here, was made after the people sinned in making the calf. There could be no question of their deserving His mercy. They deserved only wrath.
9:16
None can lay claim to God's mercy as a right. He pours out both mercy and wrath as He sees fit.
9:17
God brought Pharaoh into history for the purpose of proving His power and His name. "Pharaoh would still have been his own stubborn self if God had placed him in some obscure settlement up the Nile."
9:18
God is free and sovereign in His actions, but He is not arbitrary. Pharaoh had already hardened his heart before God hardened it. (Ex 4:21 - The LORD told Moses that when he returned to Egypt, he was to do all those wonders that God had empowered him to do in Pharaoh's sight, but that He would so harden Pharaoh's heart that Pharaoh would not release Israel. Ex 14:4 - Thus I will harden his heart, and he will chase after Israel. I will be honored through Pharaoh and his army, and all Egypt will know that I am the LORD. Ex 7:3 - I will harden his heart so that I may increase My signs and wonders in Egypt. Ex 9:12 - The LORD hardened Pharaoh's heart, and he did not listen, just as the LORD had told Moses. Ex 7:13 - Pharaoh's heart was hardened, and he wouldn't listen, even as the LORD had said would happen. Ex 8:19 - The magicians told Pharaoh that what had occurred was by the finger of God. But his heart was hardened, and he didn't listen, even as the LORD had said. Ex 8:15 - When Pharaoh saw that the plague was lifted, he hardened his heart and didn't listen to them, just as the LORD had said. Ex 7:14 - Pharaoh's heart is stubborn; he refuses to let the people go. Ex 9:7 - Pharaoh checked, and found that none of Israel's livestock had died. But his heart was hardened, and he didn't let them go. Ex 8:32 - This time, also, Pharaoh hardened his heart and didn't let them go. Ex 10:20 - The LORD hardened his heart, and he didn't let Israel go. Ex 10:27 - The LORD hardened his heart, and he wasn't willing to let them go. Ex 11:10 - Even though Moses and Aaron performed such wonders before him, the LORD hardened his heart, and he didn't allow Israel to leave his land. Ex 14:8 - The LORD hardened Pharaoh's heart, and he chased the sons of Israel as the left. Ex 10:1 - Go to Pharaoh, for I have hardened both his heart, and that of his servants, so that I might perform these signs among them.) "Moral character is a most important aspect of one's person." Pharaoh's hardening was the result of his own actions. God's actions in hardening whom He will is based on His righteousness and His freedom.
9:19
The Jews thought that God was bound to grant them prosperity now, and bliss in eternity, which view Paul has corrected. God is bound by nothing but His own righteousness. Those who are hearing this doctrine find it senseless that God would find fault with those He Himself has hardened.
9:20-9:21
Paul replies by reminding the complainant of his real situation. "A real knowledge of the true God makes such an objection preposterous." To make his point, he uses the illustration of the potter that Jeremiah had used long before (Jer 18:4-6). "One pot may be intended for carrying water and another for carrying away refuse. The same material is used for both."
9:22
If a potter can do as he pleases with his pots, certainly God can also do what He pleases with His creations. Yet, Paul is careful to note that God's relationship to those fit for destruction is different than His relationship with those fit for glory. God's patience is emphasized towards those objects of His wrath. They are being made ready, although it cannot be declared based on the text that God is the one making them ready.
9:23
In the case of the objects of His mercy, however, He is actively involved in preparing them for glory. Man's own sinful acts, his rebellious nature, combine with an environment that promotes sinfulness, and with God's judicial actions, to make him ready for destruction. (Ro 1:24 - Therefore, God left them to the impure lusts of their hearts, so that they would dishonor their own bodies. Ro 1:26 - He allowed them their degrading passions; in which the natural functions of sex were exchanged for unnatural desires. Ro 1:28 - Since they no longer saw a need to acknowledge God, He left them to the depravities of their mind, to doing things improper.) All of these things combine to prepare the vessel of wrath. As to the vessels of mercy, God prepared them for glory, and revealed the riches of His glory to them.
9:24
These vessels of mercy are those called from among both Jews and Gentiles. God's freedom and power are shown alongside His forbearance.
 
 
 

Jamieson, Fausset & Brown (12/28/01)

9:14
God's righteousness and sovereignty are now expounded as answers to two objections to the idea of personal election, the first of which is that such election is counter to God's just nature. The answer to this charge is pursued through v19. The question posed here makes no sense applied to nations, nor is the answer provided in the next verse relevant in that context. It must be seen that issues of individual election are in view.
9:15
There can be no unrighteousness where one acts within his rights. God has declared it, Himself, that He will decide upon whom He will have mercy.
9:16
Neither inward intent nor outward activity will determine God's choice. (1Co 9:24 - All run in the race, but only one wins. Run so as to win. Php 2:16 - I hold fast to the word of life, so that in the day of Christ I will have reason to glory, knowing I did not run or labor in vain. Php 3:14 - I press on toward the goal, chasing the prize of God's upward call in Christ Jesus. Php 2:12-13 - As you always have done, obey in my absence just as you did when I was there. Work out your salvation with all reverence and trembling, knowing it is God who is at work in you, both to will and to work for His pleasure.) "Both the 'willing' and the 'running' are indispensable to salvation; yet salvation is owing to neither."
9:17
Notice that Paul considers Scripture grounds enough to establish truth. God not only defends whom He will, He also punishes whom He will. 'God did not make Pharaoh evil; He only forebore to make him good, by the exercise of special and altogether unmerited grace.' (Hodge) Pharaoh's character, combined with his position, made him a fit stage upon which God's righteous displeasure against rebelliousness could be played out.
9:18
There is no other motivation that determines God's actions than His own will. Where He hardens, it is by a judicial decision, where the penalty paid is abandonment to the influence of sin. (Ro 1:24 - God gave them over to the impure lusts of their hearts, to the end that they dishonor their own bodies. Ro 1:26 - He left them to their degrading passions, to fill their sexual lusts in unnatural ways. Ro 1:28 - Since they saw no reason to acknowledge God, He left them to the depravities of their own minds, to the doing of things improper. Ps 81:11-12 - My people neither listened nor obeyed, so I left them to the stubbornness of their own hearts, to walk as they saw fit. Heb 3:8 - Don't harden your hearts as your fathers did in the wilderness, when they provoked Me. Heb 3:13 - Rather, encourage each other so long as life continues, lest any of you become hardened by the deceitfulness of sin. Mt 24:12 - It is because of increased lawlessness that most people's love will grow cold. 1Co 15:38 - God gives each seed the body He wishes, unique to itself. 2Th 2:17 - Strengthen your hearts by the comfort of good works and good words.)
9:19
If it is God who chooses and rejects, then those rejected cannot help but sin. So, why is it He punishes them? Again, the objection stated makes it clear that personal election, and that prior to any impact of personal character, is the matter being discussed. Paul answers the objection first by noting the presumptuous irreverence of all attempts to 'arraign the Creator.'
9:20
(Isa 45:9 - Woe to him who would quarrel with his Maker. He is but one vessel among many similar vessels. Does the clay ask the potter what he is doing? Does it declare that it's maker has no hands by which to make it?)
9:21
The complaint made against God is founded in miscomprehension of the relationship between God and creature. He is under obligation to none, for all have sinned and forfeited all claims to His mercy. It is in relationship to sinful and fallen man, that God is compared to the potter. All being fallen, He is free to give His grace to whom He decides to, for none can make claim to have earned it as a right. In the sovereignty of His choosing, there is no injustice.
9:22
What cause is there to complain if God delays His plans to make His power and displeasure against sin known in punishing those destined for punishment? Is His long-suffering cause to charge Him with injustice? No. If God has determined to make His wrath to be understood, it could only be by punishing some, and pardoning others. But even in punishing those whom He punishes, God acts with no undue severity, but long puts up with those affronts to Himself.
9:23
(Ro 6:4 - We have been buried with Him in the baptism of death, so that as Christ was raised from death through the glory of the Father, we too might walk in renewed life.) It is that same glory in view here, the 'glorious exuberance of divine mercy.'
9:24
That glory showed not only in His preparing us, but in His calling us at the proper time. Now, for the first time in this chapter, the Gentile inclusion is mentioned. It first had to be established that a portion of Israel remained in God's grace, else His promise to Israel would indeed have failed, in spite of any swapping in of the Gentiles. Almost imperceptibly, Paul now shifts his discourse to the subject of the Gentiles, showing them to have been included in God's plans all along, as the prophecies of Old Testament Scripture declared. (Ac 15:14 - Simon has already told us how God at first involved Himself in the business of taking a people for His name from among the Gentiles.)
 
 
 

New Thoughts (12/29/01-12/31/01)

Somewhere in the commentaries was a note that pointed out how the analogy of the potter fit both the individual and the national viewpoint. With that in mind, I want to begin by looking at a few things that seem to bear on the national issue of God's providence and sovereignty. Mr. Clarke led me to look at more of the surrounding context in Jeremiah, in his efforts to shape the argument in purely national terms. The section he focused on ends with God declaring that where He has determined to bless a nation, but that nation insists on doing evil in His sight, remaining disobedient to Him, He will rethink His plans for blessing (Jer 18:9-10). If ever there was a time to keep this in view, it would seem this is that time.

America has always seen itself as a nation established by God. The colonies were founded to provide a place where men could worship in the fashion they deemed most in accord with His teaching. Strong efforts to spread the Gospel message to the previous inhabitants of the land occupied many good men. Over the course of our history, the piety of our nation has fluctuated. We have known times of great revival, and times of awful apostasy.

Throughout each of those times of apostasy, there have stood preachers in the pulpit who have cried out in their concern over the course of life in this country. Some have deemed them foolish, others opportunistic. Today, I read of many who are warning the nation that worse things are yet to come than those we have witnessed this year. My natural inclination is to join those who brush their warning aside. However, there remains this passage we mentioned: If that nation does evil in My sight, and disobeys Me, I will think better of My plans to bless them. Can we look honestly at this nation, and claim that on the whole it follows God's law? We are a people trying to remove His law from the courts of America! Can we really claim that we obey Him? How, then, all the death sciences? How, then, all the lives offered up on the altars to convenience and 'dignity?' We don't want to consider that God may have been involved with the events of this fall. We don't want to think that He had anything to do with it, whether it be an active role or a passive one.

We've been taught for so long that God is love, that we've rather forgotten that God is also just, and righteous. We've ignored that fact that vengeance is His, and looked only to His lovingkindness and mercy. We have to recognize that God is sovereign. We can blame Satan for every little thing that we don't like, but he remains a lesser player. He cannot hunt without a permit. He cannot act without authorization from a higher source. Mr. Barnes reminds us of this fact in looking at the example of Pharaoh. He reminds us that God was perfectly capable of removing Pharaoh from the scene at any time He so chose. He is in control He controlled all that was capable of influencing Pharaoh, be it for good or ill. As the God of all providence, He had control over Pharaoh at all times. He chose to order Pharaoh's circumstances such that his true character would develop, yet in doing so left Pharaoh free to pursue his course as he pleased. Pharaoh's opposition to God was voluntary.

We must recognize that the same holds true for Mr. Ben Ladin today. God has arranged circumstances such that, as this man makes his choices, his true character is developed. God has permitted him to remain on the scene. God has raised him up to the position he occupies, whereby he can arrange such atrocities against this nation. Why? I think that in part the answer lies in the fact that He has also left this nation to its own choices, and those choices have shown a national character that gives Him cause to rethink His plans to bless us. I think that in part the answer lies in His love for His people. Whom He loves, He disciplines. We, as a nation, have needed correction. We have chosen foolishly, and followed after all too many things that are not good. The question that comes now is, what will we do with that discipline? Will we accept it, learn from it, and return to the paths of righteousness, or will we reject Him and insist on our own course?

With that question before me, I thank God for His choice of leader for this nation at this time. Never has it been so clear that He raises up the rulers He desires. Never was an election so clearly a matter of His choosing. We have been blessed to have a praying President to lead in this time of national crisis. We have watched a reprobate press that has found itself tongue-tied, being unable to find cause for criticism. What can be said of them? They have been dragged into a begrudging respect for the man they thought laughable. Yet, they continue to hunt and peck, seeking some means to drag down this offense to their immorality. But God scoffs at their efforts. He has placed His man in the seats of power, and He will determine when that man's time is up. I must note, however, that He also placed the previous President in power. Knowing that, I am all the more thankful that we have who we have at this time and for this time.

Something else struck me in looking at Luke 21:23 (Woe to those with child in those days, for there will be great distress on the land, and wrath to this people.) In the context of that declaration, it seems clearly directed at Israel. It was not declared as wrath to all people, but to this people. This struck me as rather significant to all the end-times ponderings that so occupy people's minds these days. Why did destruction come upon Jerusalem, God's chosen city? Because it was the day of vengeance, the fulfillment of what had been prophesied (Lk 21:22). And this punishment will last until the times of the Gentiles are fulfilled (Lk 21:24). Indeed, if God's people will insist on their sins, if they will persistently do evil before His eyes, and rebel against Him, He will reconsider His planned blessings. The nation of Israel, God's chosen people, has had a history that no nation would envy, and yet every nation should envy. They have suffered unbelievable catastrophes. The destruction of Jerusalem was a horrible event, not only because pagan Rome gained a more complete control over the Holy Land, but because much of the cities destruction and desecration came from Israel itself.

And this was but the beginning of her trials. The city has been overrun by so many, at so many different times, and even now, when Israel is returned to its lands, it is a land contested and cohabited. Israel is forced to reside side by side with those who have declared their hatred of Israel, who have declared their greatest intentions to be the erasing of Israel from the face of the earth. Why? What was Israel's order from God when first they entered Canaan? They were told to annihilate the inhabitants of that land, because those nations had performed such abominations against holiness, that they could no longer be tolerated. What abominations? Well, to begin with, there was their practice of offering their own children on the fires of the altar. We ought to be warned. Why annihilation? Because sin is an viral infection. It cannot be contained, it must be eradicated. God warned them of what would come if they did not remove this infection completely from their lands, but they didn't listen. They left the virus, and tried to contain it, tried to turn it to their own uses. It backfired. Those they were supposed to clean from their land now share that land with them, and lobby to have Israel removed. The virus was never contained. It just became more impervious to treatment.

The church, today, should be learning from this situation. All that is written in Scripture was written to teach us, who live at the end of all history. How many things have we refused to annihilate from among us? How many sins have we allowed to remain in the Church, thinking them contained? How tolerant have we become of debased and deceptive teaching? How can we think that God will long tolerate the pollution we bring to His body? We need to wake up, and clean up. We need to learn an intolerance for all that is not holy. We need to be intolerant of it in our houses, but moreso in His house. It is not for man to decide what is appropriate in worship. It is not for man to decide what is appropriate in doctrine. God makes the calls. We need to learn to discern. We need to learn to accept what He has decided, and to so act.

Shifting focus to the more personal matters presented in this passage, think about this: Paul presents a question on behalf of his audience, "If God's will is irresistible, why is He angry with us?" Paul's response to that question is, "Who resists Him?" All of the commentaries I've read look at this as almost a non-response. Paul is merely reminding them of their condition before God, they say. To me, however, it appears that one could take this as a legitimate answer to the question. True, God's will is irresistible, but who among you has actually tried to resist Him, and do good? Who among you has been fighting to free himself from his sins? Not one. The simple fact is that we never even try for righteousness until He comes to make the necessary change in our hearts.

There remains, however, that message of the inappropriateness of indicting God for His decisions. As with nations, so with men: He is sovereign. He is also most merciful. He has showered his blessings not only upon His chosen, but on all men. All men know the blessings of sunshine and rain, of food to sustain, and shelter to protect. All share in the many blessings of life. Recognizing this, we can join Mr. Barnes in saying, "They who have received every blessing they enjoy from Him, ought not to blame Him for not making them different." In spite of their rebellion, yet everything they have, comes from Him. Every good they have known is still by His hand, though they won't acknowledge Him, or thank Him. Where is there room for them to complain? They have been allowed to pursue their own ways, and have even been given provisions to sustain them in their pursuits. If they attain to the ends they have so pursued, is that any fault of God's?

On what basis can we conclude that God has not the right to do with us as He will? The only bonds one can find on His rights are those He Himself has placed there, and those bonds are bonds of righteousness. There is only one means by which we could possibly insist on His aid, and that is the means He chose: faith in His Son unto salvation. Yet, were it not for His influence in our hearts, not one of us would have made that choice. He chose us unto salvation. He chose to so renew our hearts, as to make it possible for us to desire the salvation He offers. No reason is ever offered in Scripture to explain why He has chosen us, and not chosen others.

Calvin declares that the reason for this lack of explanation is that God does not reveal His counsels to man. Yet, in Amos 3:7, we read that the Lord GOD does nothing without revealing His secret counsel to His servants the prophets. Some would declare that there are no prophets in the world today. This would certainly reconcile the two statements. However, I have yet to read any conclusive argument from Scripture that would indicate such an end to prophecy. In fact, if we are to accept the words Amos has declared, it would seem that the office of the prophet must continue, as Augustine points out in his writings, until there is no tomorrow about which to prophecy.

So, are both Calvin and Amos correct in their statements? If one must be rejected, it would have to be Calvin, because Scripture will stand. Yet, it seems clear to me that no prophet has ever been told who would or wouldn't be saved, nor why. In fact, Jesus' parables would tend to indicate that it is not for us to know with certainty who is saved and who isn't. Our judgment in such matters is too unreliable to allow us to make the call. Is it, then, a matter of counsels concerning nations vs. counsels concerning individuals? Maybe, but I don't see any strong support for reaching that conclusion.

How is this, Father? I confess I don't understand. If nothing is done but that You reveal it to Your prophets, how is it that we know not who is saved? This seems so contradictory. Is not salvation Your doing? That's been the whole point of this letter, hasn't it? How, then, are we to reconcile this with Your word, oh God? In Your time, would You bring understanding?

God may not clarify for us why we are chosen, but there is one thing He is absolutely clear on: He did choose us, and that, in spite of ourselves. We were a people not seeking, yet He made Himself to be found by us. We had no desire for Him, yet He came to work a change in us, that we might desire Him. He did not force us to desire Him, however, He simply made it possible for us to. He made repairs upon our nature so that it was possible for us to desire Him, where before no possibility existed.

Augustine writes, "God makes some vessels of wrath according to their merit; others, vessels of mercy according to His grace." Matthew Henry writes, "We can destroy ourselves fast enough, but we cannot save ourselves. Sinners fit themselves for hell, but it is God that prepares saints for heaven." The point is much the same. Were we to depend on our efforts, on what we have earned or deserved, there could be but one result. We would inevitably earn our destruction, for all have sinned and fallen short of God's rule of righteousness. Those who cry out for God's justice upon their case are blindly crying out for their own destruction, for that can be the only just answer to man's actions.

Yet, He is also merciful, and those who understand their true nature will cry out for His mercy. In His mercy, He moves to prepare those He has chosen for heaven. He works most directly with them, to justify, to sanctify, and to glorify. He is intimately involved with the raising of His children. Yet, nowhere can it be shown that He moves directly to prepare the wicked for destruction. We were doing that well enough on our own before He called, and where He hasn't called, such self-preparations will continue.

I was listening to a message from Mr. Sproul recently, on the end of Romans 1. In it, he pointed out that the worst judgment God ever meted out to man was to leave him to his own course, to abandon him to his own pursuits. No man was forced by God to sin. No man was ever coerced into fulfilling his own lusts. All men, at one time or another, have actively pursued that sin and lust quite of their own accord. But God so moved upon some that they changed. New desires sprung up within them, a new hunger for righteousness burned in their hearts, and they came to seek God out. They came to seek His forgiveness, and to seek salvation from their fleshly desires in the only place it could be found, in Christ Jesus. Those who have rejected that salvation, God has judged. His judgment has been that as they have decided to reject Him, so be it. Let them pursue their own course. Their end is just.

But, here is the great gift that we celebrate in Christmas celebrations: the Gift of great worth given to men of no worth. God has displayed His great mercy on all, on both Jew and Gentile. That mercy was displayed, as Mr. Clarke points out, to all who have "been invited by the preaching of the Gospel to receive justification by faith in our Lord Jesus Christ, and have come to the Gospel feast on this invitation." What greater present could He possibly give to us than His own mercy! And what mercy it is! For, Matthew Henry points out for us that "God's mercy endures forever, because the reason of it is fetched from within Himself."

Thanks be to our great God that our salvation is solely by His own choosing! Thanks be to our mighty Savior that our salvation rests upon nothing but faith alone, and even that faith a gift from Himself to us! Where else shall we find such a great and blessed assurance in knowing that we will be with Him? If it depended on my actions, on my consistent adherence to His ways, I would be doomed from the start. I could give up now, and walk away. But it's not my, my Lord, it's You! You have done it. You have made a way where no way existed! You have declared me righteous by Your word. You have washed me, You have cast my sins away. You have saved me by Your eternal mercy! How can I but rejoice in the knowledge of so great a salvation! How can I but seek to know You better, who have done such wonderful things for me!

Lord, I've looked back across my notes from the last few years, and I've noticed a change. It's become more preaching than praying. While I'm enjoying the growth in understanding, my God, I'm missing that more intimate communication we had. I pray that as I enter this new year with You, that You might work in me a new balance. I pray that You would work within me to rebuild that place of prayer that has been lacking of late, and yet work it such that this growth in study might remain.

Lord, You know the many decisions and directions that lie ahead of me in this coming year. You know the confusion that my job has become. You know the challenge that worship ministry has become. You know the questions that surround the teaching ministry You began me in last year. So much seems to be withering right now, oh God. I cling to the knowledge that every seed must fall to the ground if it is to grow to a fruitful tree. I pray that You would guide me, in each of these areas, into the place You would have me to be.

I lay it all in Your capable and wonderful hands, my Lord, for You know best. Where You would have me to go, point the way, Jesus, and I will go. Sweet Lord, I cannot rely on visions You have given to others. I cannot bring myself to make my way by dreams. I need a clear word, Holy Spirit, I need Your voice bringing to mind all that I need to know in this time of change. I pray, as I look to a meeting with Pastor this afternoon, that You would fill both him and myself with the words of Your truth. Give us together, oh Holy Spirit, the wisdom of Your counsel, by which to set course.

I cannot end this study without providing a balance to the truth of Your mercy. Paul is a wise example in this, for never does he point out that it all rests with God, without simultaneously reminding us that we must yet make every effort on our own part. In the J, F, & B commentary it says, "Both the 'willing' and the 'running' are indispensable to salvation; yet salvation is owing to neither." This is the balanced message that comes of Romans and James. Salvation is most assuredly by faith alone, yet it is a very dead faith that does not seek to do those things that are pleasing to our Savior. If we are not striving after that very righteousness that Jesus has given us, if we are not putting every effort into living a life worthy of the great price He paid for us, we have every reason to question whether that salvation is really ours. A true faith in Christ Jesus cannot but produce fruits of righteousness. Certainly, we will continue to make mistakes. This is why salvation depends on His mercy, and not on our obedience. We'll blow it, yet we must try our hardest. We cannot help but try our hardest.

Along with Paul, we must ever strain for the finish line. We must exercise and train ourselves constantly to the ways of righteousness. We must live by Nehemiah's example: striving to our utmost, as though God would not help, and simultaneously praying for God's assistance, knowing that without Him, we can do nothing. This is the Christian life: doing our utmost, yet recognizing that we can do nothing; trusting all to our God and Savior, yet seeking with all our might and will to do His will. We are a living paradox, simultaneously saint and sinner (Luther?) Knowing we must inevitably fail of perfection, yet we exert every effort to attain to that perfection, trusting Christ Jesus to complete in us that which He has begun. In all that effort, our only confidence is that He is faithful, for we know ourselves too well to declare ourselves faithful. He is faithful, and my salvation is sure! I will one day see Him face to face, as He truly is, as He welcomes me into the family house! What more do I need than to know that this is my inheritance? Surely, He alone is worthy of our praise! Give God the glory for the great things He has done in this sinner's life!