1. XV. Olivet Discourse – When Lord?
    1. K. The Sheep & the Goats (Mt 25:31-25:46)

Some Key Words (11/05/11)

Separate (aphorisei [873]):
To separate locally. To select some. This is a root of the name Pharisees, the separated ones. | from apo [575]: off or away, and horizo [3724]: from horion [3725]: from horos: a bound or limit; a boundary line or frontier; to mark out or bound, to appoint or specify. To set off by boundary, exclude or appoint. | To exclude as disreputable. To set apart for some purpose, appoint.
To the extent that (eph [1909] hoson [3745]):
/ | at or upon / from hos [3739]: who, which, what, that. As much, as great, as long. | upon, near, at the time when, in the place where, on the basis of. / for so long as, as many as. By so much as. In so far as.
Least (elachistoon [1646]):
| least in size, amount, dignity. | smallest, least. May refer to size, importance, authority, or men’s esteem.

Paraphrase: (11/05/11)

Mt 25:31-46 When the Son of Man comes in His full glory, the angels with Him, He will take His place upon His throne and judge the nations. He will separate them one from another, as a shepherd separates the sheep from the goats, putting the sheep on his right and the goats on his left. To those on the right, He will say, “Come, you whom My Father has blessed! Inherit the kingdom that was prepared for you from the foundation. For I hungered and you fed Me, I thirsted and you gave Me drink. I was naked and you gave Me clothing, sick and imprisoned, and you visited Me and ministered to Me.” The righteous will be in wonder. “Lord, when did we ever see You thus and minister to You?” He will reply, “Truly, in that you did these things for one of the least of My family, you did it to Me.” Turning to those on His left, He will command them to depart into eternal flame, cursed and committed to join the Devil and his minions. “For you did none of these things for Me.” They, too, will wonder when they ever had opportunity. He will reply that in so much as they did not help on of the least of His family, they were refusing aid to Him. Then, He will command them to depart from His presence into eternal punishment. But the righteous will proceed into eternal life.

Key Verse: (11/06/11)

Mt 25:34 – He will say to those on his right, “Come, you who are blessed by My Father and inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation.”

Thematic Relevance:
(11/06/11)

Christ regnant. The King judges who shall be His subjects.

Doctrinal Relevance:
(11/06/11)

Our inheritance was established from the beginning. The implication is that our role as inheritor was likewise established.
The Judgment will take account of deeds both for the righteous and the unrighteous.

Moral Relevance:
(11/06/11)

The balance between faith and works is one to bear in mind. The inheritance may be settled for us, but there remains a measuring of works. We cannot just take our citizenship for granted, but must be moved by the privilege of citizenship to act as citizens.

Doxology:
(11/06/11)

Here is a point of praise that has been on my mind since I first started reading this portion: Christ our Judge does not look to the failures of the chosen, but to the successes. The penalty of our myriad failures was what He paid on the cross. There is no need for Him to examine those. Instead, He brings forth the record of our successes for judgment, and as that record shows we ministered to ‘one of the least of My brothers’, it is deemed a mark of our worth! How glorious it is that my God has chosen to account my successes rather than my sins, for it is the righteous who may stand in His presence, and were He to take full account of my sins, any man’s sins, there could be no standing. But, as the song says, He has made a way where there was no way. Glory be to His name, and thanks forevermore!

Symbols: (11/06/11)

N/A

People Mentioned: (11/06/11)

N/A

You Were There (11/06/11)

While we have the leisure to lay this parable alongside the full scope of the Gospel, I would note that those disciples sitting on the hillside outside Jerusalem had no such advantage. As they heard this, I wonder how they reacted. Did they sense that the “you who are blessed by My Father” outweighed the “you did not do it to one of the least of these”? Or did they view it in the obverse? I sense that they were by no means so secure in their standing as to have grasped the full scope of what Jesus was doing on their behalf. That being the case, how sobering to hear that latter clause! Indeed, it would be enough to make a man give up trying. If one slip is all it takes to earn an eternity of punishment, there’s no sense putting any more effort into righteousness. It’s over before it began!

On the other hand, the reverse of that image is also plainly in view. If one slip was enough to condemn, in the same way, one success was enough to open the gates of heaven. This, if they thought about it hard enough, presents something of a quandary, for experience would indicate that most everybody could put at least one mark in each column. Did they see this and arrive at understanding? Did they grasp that these were not the measure by which decision was made, but the distinct systems of measurement used for a decision already made? I don’t know.

I am mindful of a song I used to have on tape with the title, “Was it For Life?” It is a question that must occasionally prick the conscience of the staunchest believer. Was it for life, or as the chorus refrains, just so long as my nose stayed clean? Is it a question of that final act, whatever we may have been about in the moment of our dying or of His returning? Or is it about a decision long since made, and made not by us but by Him? I have been on both sides of answering this question over the brief course of my faith. I was once quite confident that it was ‘just so long as my nose stayed clean’ and found in that a pretty strong incentive to do my utmost. But, then, both realizing the full scope of Scripture and the full scope of my utter inability to walk in sinless fashion, I was moved to recognize that Christ Jesus already made the call, and Scripture makes plain that He made that call from the foundation, way before I was even a zygote, let alone a being. Yes, it was and is for Life, and Life in the fullness of its intent!

Some Parallel Verses (11/07/11)

Mt 25:31
Mt 16:27-28 – The Son of Man is going to come in His Father’s glory with His angels. He will repay each according to his deeds. Indeed, some standing here today will not taste death before seeing the Son of Man coming in His kingdom. 1Th 4:16 – The Lord Himself will descend from heaven with a shout, the voice of the archangel, and with the trumpet of God. Then, the dead in Christ will rise first. 2Th 1:6-7 – It is only just that God would repay those who afflict you with afflictions of their own, giving relief to you who are afflicted now, and to us as well, when the Lord Jesus is revealed from heaven with His mighty angels in flaming fire. Heb 9:28 – Christ also, having been once offered to bear the sins of many, shall appear a second time for salvation without sin, to those who eagerly await Him. Jude 1 – Jude, servant of Jesus the Christ and brother of James, to the called, the beloved of God the Father, kept for Jesus the Christ. Rev 1:7 – See! He is coming with the clouds, and every eye will see Him, even those who killed Him. All the tribes of the earth will mourn over Him. Mt 19:28 – I tell you that you who have followed Me will sit upon twelve thrones, judging the tribes of Israel when the Son of Man sits on His glorious throne.
32
Mt 13:49 – At the end of the age the angels will come and take the wicked from among the righteous. 2Co 5:10 – We all must appear before the judgment seat of Christ, and each will be repaid as his bodily deeds have earned, whether good or bad. Eze 34:17 – As for you, My flock, “Behold, I will judge between the sheep, between the rams and the male goats.” Eze 34:20“I will judge between the fat sheep and the lean.” Mt 24:31 – He will send out His angels with a great trumpet, to gather His elect from one end of the sky to the other. Joel 3:12 – Let the nations arise and come to the valley of Jehoshaphat. There I will sit in judgment on all the surrounding nations. Mt 24:14 – This kingdom gospel will be preached throughout the world, a witness to all nations. Then, the end shall come. Mt 28:19 – Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of Father, Son and Holy Spirit.
33
1Ki 2:19 – Bathsheba spoke to Solomon about Adonijah. The king rose to meet her, bowing before her, and then sat his throne. He had a second throne set up to his right for his mother. Ps 45:9 – There are daughters of kings amongst Thy noble ladies, and the queen stands at Thy right hand dressed in gold. Ecc 10:2 – A wise man’s heart steers him to the right, but a fool’s to the left.
34
Mt 5:3 – Blessed the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven. Mt 19:29 – Everyone who ever left home or family or farm for My sake shall receive them back many times over and inherit eternal life. Lk 12:32 – Fear not, little flock, for your Father has gladly chosen to give you the kingdom. 1Co 6:9 – Don’t you know that the unrighteous won’t inherit the kingdom of God? Don’t be deceived! Fornicators, idolaters, adulterers, effeminates and homosexuals, their like will not inherit. 1Co 15:50 – Flesh cannot inherit the kingdom of God. The perishable does not inherit the imperishable. Gal 5:21 – Envying, drunkenness, carousing and the like, of which I forewarn you as I have before that those who practice such things shall not inherit the kingdom of God. Jas 2:5 – Didn’t God choose the poor of this world to be rich in faith, heirs of the kingdom He promised to those who love Him? Mt 13:35 – The prophet’s words will be fulfilled: “I will speak in parables, and utter things hidden since the foundation.” Lk 11:50 – And the blood of all the prophets, shed since the foundation, may be charged against this generation. Jn 17:24 – Father, I desire that they whom Thou hast given Me might be with Me where I am, so that they can behold My glory, that glory You have given Me. For You loved Me before the foundation of the world. Eph 1:4 – He chose us in Him before the foundation of the world, in order that we might be holy and blameless before Him. Heb 4:3 – We who have believed enter that rest, even as He said: “I swore in My wrath that they would not enter My rest,” though His works were finished from the foundation of the world. Heb 9:26 – Were it otherwise, He would have needed to suffer constantly since the foundation of the world. But now, this once at the consummation of the ages He has been manifested in order to put away sin entirely by the sacrifice of Himself. 1Pe 1:20 – He was foreknown before the foundation, but appeared in these last times for your sake. Rev 13:8 – All who dwell on the earth will worship him. Everyone whose name has not been written in the Lamb’s book of life from the foundation will be slain. Rev 17:8 – The beast that you saw was and is not, and is about to come out of the abyss to go to destruction. They who are on earth will wonder when they see the beast (they whose names are not in the book of life from the foundation of the world). They will marvel that he was and is not and will come. Isa 6:5 – Woe is me, I am ruined! I, a man of unclean lips, have seen the King, the Lord of hosts with my own eyes. Ps 110:1 – The Lord says to my Lord: “Sit at My right hand until I make Your enemies a footstool for Your feet.” Ps 37:22 – Those blessed by Him will inherit the land. Those cursed by Him will be cut off. Isa 65:23 – They shall not labor in vain, nor bear children for calamity. They are the offspring of those the Lord blessed, and He blessed their descendants with them. Eph 1:3 – Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who has blessed us with every spiritual blessing in the heavenly places in Christ. 1Pe 3:9 – Don’t return evil for evil or insult for insult. Rather, give a blessing. For you were called for the very purpose that you might inherit a blessing. Rev 21:7 – He who overcomes will inherit these things. I will be his God and he will be My son. Lk 22:29-30 – Just as My Father granted Me a kingdom, I grant you to eat and drink at My table in My kingdom, and to sit in judgment upon the twelve tribes of Israel. Mt 20:23 – Indeed, you shall drink of My cup. But, to sit on My right or on My left is not Mine to give. It is for those for whom My Father has prepared it. 1Co 2:9 – As it is written, “Things the eye has not seen nor ear heard, things which haven’t entered the heart of men: all that God has prepared for those who love Him.” Heb 11:16 – But as it is, they desire a better country, a heavenly one. Therefore God is not ashamed to be known as their God, for He has prepared a place for them.
35
Isa 58:7 – Is not the fast I choose a matter of dividing your bread with the hungry, sheltering the homeless, and clothing the naked, rather than hiding yourself from your own flesh? Eze 18:7-9 – If a man does not oppress anyone, returns the debtor’s pledge to him, doesn’t rob, and gives bread to the hungry, clothes the naked; if he does not lend for interest and keeps himself from iniquity, executing justice between men; if he obeys My laws and deals faithfully: Then he is righteous and will assuredly live. Eze 18:16-17 – If he does not oppress, keep the pledge when the loan has been repaid, or rob; if he instead feeds the hungry and clothes the naked, if he does not abuse the poor, taking interest on loans to them, but rather executes My laws; he will not die for his father’s sins, but will surely live. Jas 2:15-16 – If a brother is without cloths or needs food, and you do no more than say, “Go in peace. Be warm and filled!” without giving them what is necessary for those ends, what use is that? Job 31:32 – The alien has not been left to sleep outside, for I have opened my doors to travelers. Heb 13:2 – Don’t neglect hospitality towards strangers, for some have entertained angels unawares in being thus hospitable. Ro 12:13 – Contribute to the needs of the saints and practice hospitality. Heb 13:1 – Let love of the brethren continue.
36
Jas 1:27 – This is pure, undefiled religion as God defines it: Visit orphans and widows in their distress, and keep yourself unstained by the world. 2Ti 1:16-18 – May God have mercy on the house of Onesiphorus, for he has often refreshed me, not being ashamed of my chains. When he was in Rome, he sought me out eagerly and found me. God grant that he find the Lord’s mercy upon him daily! You know full well the services he rendered at Ephesus. Lk 10:33-34 – A certain Samaritan came upon him and had compassion. He bandaged that one’s wounds, pouring oil and wine on them. Then, he put that one on his own beast, brought him to an inn, and cared for him.
37
38
39
40
Lk 19:38 – Blessed is the King who comes in the name of the Lord! Peace in heaven and glory in the highest! Rev 17:14 – These will war against the Lamb, and the Lamb will overcome them. For He is Lord of lords and King of kings. Those with Him are called, chosen and faithful. Rev 19:16 – His name is upon His robe and on His thigh: “King of kings and Lord of lords.” Pr 19:17 – He who is gracious to the poor lends to the Lord. The Lord will repay him for his goodness. Mt 10:42 – Whoever gives a cup of water to one of these little ones in the name of a disciple shall by no means lose his reward. Heb 6:10 – God is not unjust, forgetting your work and your love for Him shown in ministering to the saints. Mt 10:40 – He who receives you receives Me. He who receives Me receives Him who sent Me. Mt 28:10 – Don’t be afraid. Take word to My brothers to go to Galilee, and they shall see Me there. Jn 20:17 – Stop clinging to Me! I have not yet ascended to the Father. Go, now, and tell My brothers. Tell them, “I ascend to My Father and yours, My God and yours.” Ro 8:29 – Whom He foreknew, He predestined to be conformed to the image of His Son, that His Son might be the first-born of many brothers. Heb 2:11 – He who sanctifies and those who are sanctified are all from one Father. It is thus that He is not ashamed to call them brothers. Mt 12:50 – Whoever does My Father’s will is My brother, My sister, My mother.
41
Mt 7:23 – I will say to them, “I never knew you. Depart from Me, you lawless ones.” Mk 9:48 – Their worm does not die, and the fire is never quenched. Lk 16:24 – He cried out, “Father Abraham, have mercy on me! Send Lazarus to dip his finger in water and cool my tongue, for I am in agony in this flame.” Mt 4:10 – Begone, Satan! For it is written, “You shall worship the Lord your God, and serve only Him.” Rev 12:9 – The dragon, that ancient serpent the devil called Satan who deceives the whole world, was thrown down to earth, and his angels with him. Heb 6:8 – If it yields thorn and thistle, it is worthless and near to being cursed. It ends up being burned. Mt 13:40-42 – Just as tares are gathered up and burned, so the end of the age. The Son of Man will send His angels out to gather all stumbling blocks out of His kingdom, all those who are lawless, and they will cast these into the furnace of fire. In that place will be weeping and gnashing of teeth. Mt 18:8, Mk 9:43 – If your hand or foot makes you stumble, cut it off! Better life as a cripple than eternal fire with all limbs intact. Mk 9:48 – In that place worm does not die and fire is not quenched. 2Th 1:8 – He will deal retribution to those who don’t know God and who don’t obey the gospel. 2Pe 2:4 – God didn’t spare those angels who sinned, but cast them into hell, committed them to pits of darkness to be preserved for judgment. Rev 12:7 – There was war in heaven as Michael and his angels battled the dragon and his.
42
Job 22:7 – You have given no water to the weary, and you have kept bread from the hungry.
43
44
45
Lk 10:16 – The one who listens to you listens to Me. The one who rejects you rejects Me, and in rejecting Me, rejects the One who sent Me. Ac 9:5 – Saul said, “Who are You, Lord?” And Jesus replied, “I am Jesus whom you are persecuting.” 1Co 8:12 – By sinning against your brothers, wounding their conscience in its weakness, you sin against Christ.
46
Dan 12:2 – Many who sleep in the ground will awake, some to everlasting life, others to everlasting disgrace and contempt. Jn 5:29 – They shall come forth; those who did good to a resurrection of life, those who did evil to a resurrection of judgment. Ac 24:15 – I have the same hope in God that these men so cherish, being certain that there shall be a resurrection both of the righteous and of the wicked. Jn 3:15 – Whoever believes in Him may in Him have eternal life. Jn 3:36 – He who believes in the Son has eternal life. He who doesn’t obey the Son shall not see life, but rather the abiding wrath of God. Jn 5:24 – He who hears My word and believes Him who sent Me has eternal life. He does not come into judgment, but has already passed out of death into life. Jn 6:27- Don’t labor for perishable food. Work for that food which endures to eternal life, that food the Son of Man shall give you. For on Him God the Father has set His seal. Jn 6:40 – This is My Father’s will, that everyone who sees the Son and believes in Him may have eternal life. I Myself will raise him up on the last day. Jn 6:47 – I tell you in all truth that he who believes has eternal life. Jn 6:54 – He who eats My flesh and drinks My blood has eternal life. I will raise him up on the last day. Jn 17:2-3 – Just as you granted Him authority over all mankind, He may give eternal life to all whom You have given Him. This is eternal life: That they may know You, the only true God, and Jesus the Christ whom You sent. Ac 13:46-48 – Paul and Barnabas were bold to speak: “It was required that God’s word should be spoken first to you. By rejecting it, you have judged yourselves as unworthy of eternal life, so behold! We go to the Gentiles, for God has commanded us, saying, ‘I have placed You as a light for the Gentiles, that You should bring salvation to the end of the earth.’” Ro 2:7 – Those who seek glory, honor and immortality by persevering in doing good shall receive eternal life. Ro 5:21 – Sin reigned in death. Just so, grace shall reign through righteousness to eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord. Ro 6:23 – The wages of sin is death. But the free gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord. Gal 6:8 – The one who sows to his own flesh shall reap from that flesh corruption. The one who sows to the Spirit shall reap from the Spirit eternal life. 1Jn 5:11 – This is the witness: God has given us eternal life, and that life is in His Son.

New Thoughts (11/08/11-11/11/11)

I did not take time to explore the imagery of this parable during my preparations, but they are certainly deserving of some consideration. What, for example, would have been understood of the distinction between sheep and goats, or between the right hand and left hand side? On the first matter of sheep and goats, I find I left myself a note at some point to look at Exodus 12:5 when I arrived at this passage. There, Moses is describing the preparations for the Passover. Speaking in particular of that animal which would be sacrificed for the meal, he writes, “Your lamb shall be an unblemished male a year old; you may take it from the sheep or from the goats.” Well, this is interesting, if only in that we don’t typically think of lambs as being anything distinct from sheep. We would not typically think of a young goat as a lamb, but rather as a kid.

So, then, in the matter of the Passover which foreshadowed Christ’s offering of Himself, it didn’t matter particularly whether a sheep or a goat was offered. Yet here, there is a clear distinction being made. A quick look at Fausset’s indicates that sheep are symbolic of “meekness, patience, gentleness and submission.” It is also noted that sheep were created specifically for mankind, never having existed in wild form. It is thus, the text says, that the sheep was chosen for the first sacrifice. As to goats, there are several Hebrew words represented, one referring to the leader of the flock, and sometimes significant of being headstrong, wanton and lustful. Another term describes a different breed of goat used for the sin offering, and this is also an image used for evil spirits. Then, of course, there is the scapegoat.

In the matter of the sin offering, there is something of interest to be seen. The male goat was used for the sin offering, along with a calf, whereas an ox and a ram made up the peace offering (Lev 9:3-4). As to the scapegoat, it was selected from two goats. There are other matters worth noting in that matter. First, the process was established in the aftermath of the death of Aaron’s sons (Lev 16:1). Second, the whole was set in place as preparation for Aaron entering the Holy place (Lev 16:3). The offering he was to make consisted of bull and ram, which seems to parallel the peace offering described earlier. Then, there were matters of purification to be seen to. Finally, two goats were to be taken from the sons of Israel, one for a sin offering and one for a burnt offering (Lev 16:5). This is where the matter of the scapegoat comes in, for one goat would be chosen by lot to be ‘for the Lord’. The other would be the scapegoat. The one chosen for the Lord was offered as a sin offering, but the scapegoat was ‘presented alive before the Lord, to make atonement upon it,’ and then sent off into the wilderness (Lev 16:8-10). There is much more preparation involved in this passage, as it pertains to the Day of Atonement. But this imagery suffices for the moment.

As applied to the passage from Matthew, it seems that the distinction between sin offering and peace offering might best be kept in view. The sheep, the peace offering, are welcomed. The goats, the sin offering, are sent to the fires of punishment.

As to the distinction between left and right, this appears almost a universal bit of lore. There is the consistent association of right and correct, and also the equally consistent association of left and sinister. There is much that could be said of this in regard to our political scene, but leave that aside. What I found rather striking is that we see this same general perception in Solomon’s writings. “A wise man’s heart steers him to the right, but a fool’s to the left” (Ecc 10:2). Why, Solomon? Well, there is a sense of the right hand as being the stronger, the more dexterous and skillful. It is from the right hand that the sovereign dispenses blessings. Vine’s notes that God taking one’s right hand indicates His strengthening and aid. The term for left has associations with darkness, or being wrapped up. There is a sense of unluckiness to it. TWOT notes that quite often left and right simply describe two options with no further implications. But, there are these cases, both in Ecclesiastes and here in Matthew where a moral distinction is clearly implied.

Does any of this greatly influence how we ought to understand what Jesus says here? Let us associate the two sets of images. On the right, the side of God’s blessing and aid, we have the peace offering acceptable to Father. On the left side, wrapped in darkness are the goats of the sin offering. There, we might note that those caught upon in habitual sin are indeed wrapped in darkness and unable to see the Light of God. The sheep of the right hand, however, know the Shepherd’s voice and will follow no other (Jn 10:4-5). They see Him leading their way and remain on course.

Now, lest there be any prideful thought that arises from being a sheep, it should be noted that sheep are just as thoroughly capable of straying as ever a goat would be, else there would be much less need for the shepherd. Sheep are notorious, at least in our modern conceptions, as being rather incapable of seeing beyond the end of their noses, for being rather flighty. Without the shepherd’s sure guidance, they would wander off a cliff without noticing, would idle away their time in mindless play and grazing. Goats, on the other hand, are mischievous as we see them. More likely, they are just curious explorers not unlike our own early years. But, that curiosity more often than not is seen as mischievousness by those who have charge over the well being of the curious.

Here, however, I shall begin to turn my thoughts in another direction, by noting that the distinction between sheep and goat has less to do with their inherent nature than with their assigned purpose. Returning to that matter of the Paschal meal, recall that either sheep or goat would do. Consider that by and large, the flocks of the shepherd would be a mix of both sheep and goat. It was only as one came to the matter of offering that distinction arose. Was the offering for peace or for sin? That determined the proper choice. Applying that to the words Jesus speaks in this passage, it could be said that those arriving at His throne of judgment already display the judgment in their being. The sheep are already marked out as peace offerings by the very fact that they are sheep and not goats. The goats are already marked out as sin offerings by the very fact that they are goats and not sheep.

We arrive, then, at an apparent issue of predestination. As something by way of a defense against the idea that I am reading into the passage from my own opinions, I note the final clause of verse 34. “Inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world.” Let me just say this: God doesn’t waste His time. He would not prepare a kingdom for you and then leave you to lose that inheritance. He doesn’t build houses to have them stand empty for all eternity. Neither does He build for one but then give to another instead. His purposes are yea and amen. We should also be ever mindful that He knows the end from the beginning, indeed, He declares the end from the beginning, if we wish to quote the passage correctly (Isa 46:10). And note what follows: “My purpose will be established, I will accomplish all My good pleasure.” That is the certainty upon which we establish hope. Who will? He will.

Come back to that inheritance. He declared it from the beginning. He did not declare that maybe someday, you would come into being. He declared you would. He did not assign some probability that maybe, just maybe, you would come to faith. He declared you would. He did not offer up prayers to Himself that perhaps you might respond and hold fast so as to overcome. He declared you would, and when He declares, He determines! He alone is the One Who is able to state the end with absolute certainty from the outset because He is the Sovereign, Almighty God. What He says goes, and it goes because He powers it. When Paul wrote, “In Him we live and move and have our being” (Ac 17:28), he wasn’t talking about our predilections. He was talking about first causes. Apart from Him, we do not live. It has nothing to do with whether we choose to acknowledge it, or choose to thank Him for it. It has to do with the fact that He is the Source. He is Life, and where He is not, there is not life. If He ceases to keep His attention on our being for the briefest of moments, we cease to be. Apart from Him, there is no being.

And, He Who alone causes all existence says, “Your inheritance has been waiting for you since the world was created.” Let’s be clear: if the inheritance was established from the very outset of earth’s existence, so too was our role as inheritor. Before ever I was born, nigh on infinitely before I was born, this was established, and it was established with the certainty that only God can establish. It is written.

[11/10/11] I need to back up briefly this morning, as I have noticed a more solid connecting of thoughts as regards the matter of left hand and right. Re-reading verse 34, it struck me: The King says to those on His right – the right hand of blessing – “Come you who are blessed of My Father”. And yes, there it is: The verb ‘blessed’ is in the perfect tense, that indicator of a past accomplishment with continuing effect. Likewise the matter of the cursed in verse 41. So, then, the results of judgment are blessing and cursing, and at the same time the basis upon which that judgment is made is prior blessing or cursing. Do I strain too hard in arriving at this conclusion? It certainly reflects that matter of predestination that has been settled within me since I studied Romans. But, the question remains as to whether the subject is truly present here. I believe it is. I believe I have already made note of its presence in the remainder of verse 34, with its point that the inheritance of the blessed was established from the foundation of the world. It was always part of the plan.

I believe I have also touched on the point that if our inheritance was thus established, so was our position as inheritor. For this point, I will indeed hear from Scripture at large. Paul, perhaps the clearest proponent of predestinarian thinking in Scripture, writes, “He chose us in Him [Christ] before the foundation of the world, in order that we might be holy and blameless before Him” (Eph 1:4). Note the very clear cause and effect in that verse. He chose us long and long before we were brought into being. He did so in Christ. In other words, the role of the Christ in this whole process was also established at the outset. And He did this so that we could be holy and blameless. Even at the outset, it was impossible that we would arrive at that estate on our own. It is His choosing that empowers and enables our holiness.

Yet, it is not Paul alone who promotes this point. John saw it, too. It is particularly evident in his discussion of the Lamb’s book of life in the Revelation. Two points are made, one of which I may return to later. First, in Revelation 13:8, after noting that all who are on the earth will worship this antichrist who comes, John notes that all those whose names were not written in the Lamb’s book of life from the foundation of the world will be slain. Notice that: This book was written and completed at the foundation, at the outset. There has been no update or revision since. This should be kept in mind as we come to Revelation 21:7, when we read that He who overcomes will inherit. The two are so thoroughly interconnected as to be inseparable. Those not in the book will not inherit, and those who are will. The implication is that those who are in the book will also overcome. They will persevere and persist. Why? Because God.

We can also hear hints of this point in some of the earlier words of Jesus. In particular, I have in mind John 5:24. “He who hears My word and believes Him who sent Me has eternal life. […] He has already passed out of death into life.” It’s already settled. And, my friend, bear firmly in mind that he who believes does so because God. God has called and the answer was nigh on inevitable. God imparts His Holy Spirit, changes the heart of stone to heart of flesh, and that new heart could hardly fail to respond to Him. It is, after all written. It was there in the Book of Life that I should be saved, that I should come to Him with a love so deep, that I should spend the remainder of my days seeking Him, seeking to become more like Him, and stumbling inevitably. Yet, it is written and I shall because God.

Now, then: Let’s take that verse from John as a transition point. The part I excised from the quote is this: “He does not come into judgment.” This pertains to those who hear and believe. Yet, here is Jesus telling us that both the redeemed and the accursed arrive at the throne of Judgment. So, which is it? Let’s have a look. First, in the verse from John, the term rendered judgment is krisin which, though it can refer to either a positive or a negative ruling, is often used to indicate condemnation, damnatory judgment. Here, the term is not present, although the concept is. Instead we are viewing a separating, aphorisei, a calling out if you like. Note that term’s association with the Pharisees, the called out ones. Here, however, the sheep are truly the called out, or culled out if you please.

Laying these two points alongside one another, it becomes more evident that what is in view here is not the deliberation, but the penalty phase. The judgment has long since been made, arguably from the foundation. This is result. And here, as we learn that we who are sheep are counted as citizens of the heavenly kingdom, indeed inherit that kingdom, which would suggest some degree of ownership or rule therein, we ought to bear in mind both the privilege and responsibility of that citizenship.

Allow me to reinforce this point just a bit: Just as our position was established from the foundation, so we are granted to know the outcome well in advance. We already know how this works out. We know we shall inherit and we know, also, that we are citizens of that kingdom even now, for we have already passed out of death into life. We know that we are but strangers and sojourners in this life, with eyes upon a city more well founded, a kingdom that never fades. Knowing this, we ought not, must not take our citizenship for granted. It is true, assuredly, of our situation as citizens of heaven. It is equally true of our situation as citizens of earth, as Paul makes plain in Romans 13. For, as citizens of earth, we remain ambassadors of heaven, and ought, as such, to be the best of citizens, most fully mindful of civic responsibilities, most fully heedful as to the law of the land, but always with our primary allegiance remaining with heaven’s King.

So, what is the privilege of citizenship? Seems to me we have the simplest of answers to that question. There is that little matter of eternal life, which is privilege indeed. Then, there is the fact that we shall spend that eternal life in the very immediate presence of our Lord and King. And, if that’s insufficient, there is also our standing as His bride. We are made royalty by His royalty. The kingdom, quite frankly, belongs to us, as He makes us inheritors thereof. But, as is so often said, with privilege comes responsibility. To put it in Biblical terms, to whom much has been given, much will be required. And, my fellow believers, we have been given much indeed!

Turning to the responsibilities that accrue, we do well to consider Paul’s several lists of what things are not welcome in this kingdom of ours. We cannot, in short, continue to pursue the course of unrighteousness and still think ourselves inheritors. “Don’t you know that the unrighteous won’t inherit?” Paul asks the Corinthians (1Co 6:9). That’s a warning shot. There is no such thing as a carnal Christian, as much as we love the term. It’s an oxymoron. It does not compute. One is either carnal or one is not, and the clear indication is that the carnal do not inherit, and if they do not inherit they are not of Christ. And if they are not of Christ they are not Christians. So, Paul continues, and note the first words well: “Don’t be deceived! Fornicators, idolaters, adulterers, effeminates and homosexuals won’t inherit.” The list actually continues to include thieves, covetous folk, drunkards, swindlers and revilers (1Co 6:10). This same general notice is given to the Galatians (Gal 5:19-21), under the heading of ‘deeds of the flesh’.

There’s more there, harder matters because they are more mundane. Enmities and strife, angry outbursts, disputes and dissensions, factionalism and envy are in the lists. These are far greater dangers to us than matters of idolatry, sorcery and fornication for the very reason that they strike us as benign. They are not so blatantly in violation of the Law, and we can easily put on our own Pharisaical garb and play at being in compliance while still entertaining such traits. So, Paul makes clear that he is not just making an aside. “I forewarn you just as I have before: Those who practice such things will not inherit the kingdom.”

Later in his letter to Corinth, he simplifies this to a very basic tenet: Flesh cannot inherit the kingdom, because the perishable never inherits imperishability (1Co 15:50). It cannot. Now all of this is not written to make us cringingly and fearfully attentive to our every act and thought. We are to be attentive, to be sure, but not with that panic and concern that supposes our eternal reward hinges on perfect compliance. No! Our concern is, or should be, that our actions reflect that eternal reward already ours. Paul’s point, as we see so clearly in that first bit to the Corinthians, is that we not delude ourselves in thinking ourselves saved when we are not. “Don’t be deceived!”

Hear me on this: The sinner’s prayer does not save. Putting name and address on a slip of paper claiming to have accepted Christ does not save. Attending church on a regular basis does not save any more than does attending only on the two high holy days of Christmas and Easter. What saves is real faith, and that faith is not something innate to ourselves, nor is it something we can work up. It is the free gift of God, that no man should boast (Eph 2:8-9). The point Paul is making in these lists of fleshly works, and the corollary lists of spiritual characteristics is to provide us with something of a self-check. If we are still consistently pursuing these sorts of actions then we ought not to suppose ourselves counted amongst the elect. Simply put, where the Spirit of the Lord is, and His abiding within is the singular hallmark and signature of faith, His fruits cannot help but be evident. You can look at Galatians 5:22-23 for a list of those character traits that are symptomatic of the indwelling Spirit of God. In Romans, the overall effect is more succinctly stated: “Those who seek glory, honor and immortality by persevering in doing good shall receive eternal life” (Ro 2:7). It might be better had Paul reversed the clauses there. Those who receive eternal life shall necessarily be those who seek glory, honor and immortality by consistently, doggedly doing good.

There are plenty of folks who are seeking glory and honor, and many who establish for themselves an immortality of sorts. That is, after all, the stuff from which history is woven. The heroes of ancient Greece are still well known to us today. The heroes of Rome are likewise immortalized in story and in stone. But, its not the personal goals that Paul tells us define the redeemed. Nor, I should note, is it the absence of such goals. It is the means and the motive. The means that count are those of persevering in doing good. Pursue that thought. What does it mean? It means those who are truly in Christ will do good even when it’s annoying, even when it involves doing so for those we might not particularly like. It means we will do good even if it comes at great personal cost to ourselves. In short, we will do good and do what is right regardless. That’s the perseverance part. Regardless of the recipient’s worth, regardless of the personal cost, regardless of the difficulties that present themselves, we shall see good done, because God is good.

Can I just note that, if I take Paul’s words here, it’s okay that there may be a bit of self-serving in that. It’s okay that maybe we allow some thought for our glory and honor in that. But, only some! We ought to desire to be known and remembered, but we must desire to be known and remembered for the ways in which we reflected and manifested Christ in us. After all, if He indwells and this necessarily results in the fruits of His Spirit being demonstrably evident in our lives, we should expect to be honored for that – not demand, but expect. Those who witness Him through us ought to glorify what they witness. The saint is worthy of praise insomuch as he is a saint. But, the saint recognizes fully that whatever praise and honor accrue to him in the minds of those around him accrues not to him but to Christ. He is pleased insomuch as he has brought honor to the only True God. It is one of those privileges of citizenship that we are empowered by Christ to have Him in evidence in our own acts and deeds.

If, then, we be remembered for aught, may it be for our evident, consistent resemblance to the Christ our Lord and Husband. May it be that we are known for having truly demonstrated our citizenship in heaven throughout our sojourn on earth.

I must say, as I start another day’s notes, that I become more and more convinced that what Jesus is describing here is not the process of judgment but rather the outcome, the sentencing phase. I have already pointed this out, but let it be repeated. Any one of us, standing before His throne on that glorious day, could assuredly find evidence befitting the summary given of the sheep. Any one of us could just as assuredly find evidence more akin to the description of the goats. The worst of sinners has almost undoubtedly done something nice for someone once in their lives, maybe even for one who is counted as family to the Christ. The best of Christians has undoubtedly missed at least one opportunity to serve a fellow believer in their need. If, then, what Jesus is showing us is the cause for the decisions He renders, then there is a double standard at play, and there comes to be a question as to the justice of it all. Yet, it is impossible that He would be unjust.

I note, also, that both sheep and goat are presented as being unaware of the significance of the deeds He recites or their lack. The sheep did not do as they did with some conscious thought of serving Christ by serving His followers. The goats did not actively seek to avoid serving Christ by not serving His followers. What Jesus is laying out here is not the intentional works done either in hopes of achieving righteousness or avoiding the same. These are the more or less unconscious acts He is listing, things done or not done based on the person before the actor. The emphasis on ‘the least of these’ causes us to consider our assessments of those we deem insignificant. Because it is our treatment of their like that our Lord finds significant. It is our treatment of such as they that provides a measure of our true character.

But, again: We know well that we who have been called by Christ are in this life simultaneously saints and sinners, as Martin Luther said. We know we have credits on both sides of that tally. If, then, Jesus takes account of every success and every failure, there is weight contributed to both sides of the scales of Justice. Here, we have to consider how we ought to understand the phrase eph hoson, which the NASB renders ‘to the extent that’. Other translations, like Webster’s offer it as ‘inasmuch as’. And the Dhouey-Reims gives us ‘as long as’. Let me take slightly more of that last one: “as long as you did it to one of these”, or “as long as you did it not”. That’s the contrast we are shown.

Looking at these translations, the sum seems to be that just one such act or one such oversight would suffice to seal the result. One slip up, and condemnation is determined. One success and heaven is assured. But, again: look back even a week and you can be pretty sure to find cause to be assured of both outcomes, if this is the basis of judgment. Yet, both outcomes cannot simultaneously apply. One cannot be found both goat and sheep. There’s no third column down the middle of this scene, else the vast majority would be found in that column. In short, this cannot be the basis of judgment. Rather, it seems as though it’s the explanation handed to those already judged.

Look at this again: The sheep cannot believe they’ve been found sheep. When did we ever earn this? Well, in truth, you didn’t. There is no earning it. Indeed, if the sheep are given to hear the results spoken to the goats, they must surely scratch their heads and think, “but, I’m just as guilty of such neglectfulness, so why am I over here?” The guilty might also find cause to wonder why the times they did act to aid another’s need aren’t being mentioned. Where do I arrive with all this? Quite simply that if this were the sole measure by which judgment were made, then there would be every cause to cry out against injustice. There would be a double standard so blatant that even those benefiting from it found it unreasonable.

That being the case, what I must suppose we are seeing here is more reflective of the legal standing already established. Bear in mind what is said of our sins on other occasions, that by His death our sins are forgiven and essentially removed from the books. If they are removed, what remains, but the list – however brief – of our deeds of compliance? He Who chooses to forget our sins as we lay hold of His forgiveness has only our good works to remember! Even if it was just one of the least of His brethren that we were mindful to aid, and aided just because it was right, not as some ticket to heaven, that’s what will be remembered into eternity.

What is markedly disturbing is the obverse of this coin. For the reprobate, the exact opposite would seem to apply. Whatever good things they may have done in life are blotted out by their refusal to have faith and submit to the Lord’s plan. The only thing that the Lord will recall of them into eternity is the long list of their sins, and it will be remembered with no least good deed to ameliorate, for the punishment shall be as eternal as the life of the saints.

My initial perspective on this was that indeed the Judge was applying two distinct systems of measurement based upon the decisions cast in concrete at the foundation of the world. However, as I have been exploring just now, this would be unjust and therefore cannot be the case. Rather, what I believe we are shown here is the two distinct outcomes or results of the judgment. This is the situation after decision has been rendered and the court documents updated. For the righteous: every crime pardoned and removed from the record. For the reprobate: every crime written for all eternity, and every ameliorating circumstance rejected and denied as having any bearing on the case.

If there are two things that seem to stand out as of primary concern from this parable, it is oddly enough not what lies on the surface. A surface reading would either cause one to just give up because the sentence of condemnation was already so clearly earned, or to start striving at works with no greater purpose in mind than to earn one’s ticket in. And, both of these responses would represent an utter failure to grasp the reality of God and of His purposes. The whole weight of Scripture points out the foolishness of both conclusions. Flesh cannot win its way into immortality. No man reaches the end of his days sinless. Scripture is adamant about this. Enoch is often raised as being the exception to this rule, but I am not convinced that holds. Enoch is exceptional, to be sure, but sinless? The remainder of Scripture would argue against any such conclusion.

This is not a call, then, to a works based approach to salvation. No! That is dead and done away with. Indeed, go back to the first statement of the Judge: that kingdom was prepared for you from the foundation of the world. This was settled long and long ago, well before the dreams which led to the eldest member of your family tree being born to their parents. Let’s be clear. Before Adam, this was already settled. The end had been declared from the beginning by the Beginning. The Alpha proclaimed the Omega, and does anybody really dare suppose they can gainsay Him to any avail?

So keep these things in view: First, that the finale was cast and determined before the curtain rose; second, that those who come to reward have not done so because of conscious effort on their part, at least not by conscious attempts to earn their way in. Nope. “When did we ever do anything right?” That seems to be the heart response of the redeemed. Arguably, it is the goats who are more keenly aware of their attempts to do right. The redeemed, it seems, tend to be far more keenly aware of their failures than their successes. Isn’t that the way of it?

Even last night at worship practice, some whom I would look upon as very reflective of what faith looks like expressed concerns along these lines. What if we come to the end and discover that we weren’t among the called after all? How can we know that we shall not be amongst those who called Him, “Lord, Lord,” and yet were never known by Him? It’s well and good to point out that these very pricks of our conscience are evidence in themselves that we are His. The reprobate, as a rule, could not care less, even as we could not have cared less about what God thought of us when we had no thought for Him.

That aside, we all know those times of concern, of wondering if our sins will, in the end, outweigh our good deeds. But, that’s all wrong-headed thinking and we know it. The good deeds either express the inward change that He has already accomplished in us or they are of no value whatsoever. All our righteousness is as filthy rags (Isa 64:6), and if we are found to be standing in the presence of our Lord and King it is because by His own right arm, He has already blessed us, and given us to be another brand plucked from the fire. It is because He has removed the filthiness of our lame attempts at righteousness and clothed us with His own real and perfect Righteousness (Zech 3:2-4).

The one last point I would make as to this matter of sheep and goats is that it stands as clear evidence of a dual resurrection. This ought be no matter of conjecture or debate in the Church. It is well established. We have it from Paul, in his defense before Felix. “I have the same hope in God that these men so cherish. I and they are equally certain that there shall be a resurrection both of the righteous and of the wicked” (Ac 24:15). Only one group will be happy about it, though. If that does not suffice, we have the words of Jesus Himself, as He discusses His role as Life giver and Judge. “Do not marvel! The hour is coming when all who are in the tombs shall hear His voice and come forth. Those who did good will be resurrected to Life. Those who did evil are resurrected to Judgment” (Jn 5:28-29). I really find no reason to comment further upon this than to simply note the established fact of this being the reality of the case. Those who suppose that they can just enjoy life while it lasts and move on to the oblivion of the grave fail to grasp the seriousness of the issue. No, no. Life does indeed persist in one form or another. But, for the sinner, the unrepentant reprobate, that which persists could hardly be counted a life worth living. Sadly, it will be a life with no expiration date and no possibility of parole.

Lord, God, this is a time to be thankful indeed, and indeed I am thankful. That You have chosen me remains one of those mysteries I shall never begin to understand. The mind wants to discover a reason for it, and the ego wants that reason to be found within the self, yet it is not there to be discovered. Who am I that You should care? I am nothing. You are all. Yet, I sit here this morning, keenly, painfully aware of my myriad shortcomings and yet utterly certain of my listing in Your book of Life. What cause have I for any such certainty except that You have spoken it? Were it not for the constant reassurance of the Holy Spirit within, I should swiftly fall into doubt and despair. But, You are here. You have chosen me for reasons only You can know, and I could hardly do other than to bless You for having blessed me. How great Your love for me, how unfathomable! How deep my debt to You for the redemption You have caused to be mine. And yet, You offer – nay decree – so great an inheritance above and beyond! What thanks could ever suffice? What words could ever be enough? How could eternity even hope to provide time enough to contain my response to such goodness! You are great, Lord. You do miracles, but this is so beside the point! You have already done the miracle in that I have found myself loving You; You of whom I gave no thought, You who I thought but a vaporous imagination, and of no value or concern. Yet, You are my all in all, my every best thought, the reason of my being and the joy of my contemplation. All praise, and glory and honor to You, Lord, and thanks unto the ages.